Agreed, I give the guy all the credit for hanging in for 6 years and as mentioned before his strength in raising capital and marketing. He's definitely not ordinary.
But in the end - does he have a sustainable business, where he gave back to the community? Is he in the ranks of a stable company owner, who can finance his children's and his employees's children's college education etc.? I know people like this and I don't know that much about how hard it was for them to outlast. But this is the measure of success. Not the 'almost' go-big-go-bust success displayed annoyingly in many American business zines (Inc, Fast Company, Business Week, Wired etc.) during the dot-com era... and this recent article.
Daimler-Benz, Siemens, GE... they are all still here and it took them a long time to grow. History is on my side on this issue: 2 major market crashes - dot-com and now real estate. My family lost a good portion of their retirement money as many others have. The end result of so much hype in the market is hazardous to society.
Summarizing, raising capital with inflated growth targets is a thing of the 90s. Growing a business slowly is the way to go, unless you have a major technology or product breakthrough.
I must add - this is a personal view. Many others will still achieve success growing quickly.
There are plenty of villains worthy of your scorn, from banksters to bureaucrats to politicians. Yet you blame a business-building job-creating entrepreneur for trying to grow too quickly? Daimler, Siemens, et al were once the size of Switch Beverage Co, and their initial investors also took big risks for the expectation of big returns. Had this guy succeeded in creating the next Coca-Cola, you probably would have been singing his praises ten years hence. It sounds like what you really object to is failure.
BTW, the next time you try to raise money, be sure to show deflated growth targets to your prospective investors, then let us know how that works out.
Further, I strongly object to the sensationalist reporting of such business magazines. Why don't we hear more about the quiet guys slugging it through and building something lasting?
Also, I don't fancy yet another beverage product on an already overcrowded consumer market and the tendency of the business owner to believe that he can only succeed by growing big fast. Why doesn't he believe in the strength of his product. If it's good, people will buy. He inherently believes people only will buy it if it's big. And that's wrong with the picture.
He has not created any new knowledge on how to make beverages and trained specialized staff accordingly, which would create positive skill feedback loops in the region of his plant. He's buying juice wholesale and outsourcing production to a local plant that makes everything from Coca-Cola to beer. This is just all marketing: take two kinds of juice, mix em, carbonate it and market the crap out of it. Where are the jobs created out of that? And I don't think he has created a viable plan for young people to follow his footsteps: the plan was to go big and he went bust. His only lasting legacy seems to be staff turnover.
Further, I suspect flaws in his management style, because it seems like he's putting out fires constantly. Something's not right here.
I don't think the world needs more entrepreneurs like him. He's clearly a very financially motivated guy, who doesn't believe in growing a great product organically. We need more great product companies instead! (Ironically, "the switch" does sound like a really neat product: 100% healthy juice)
Historically, companies that had product experts (engineers) in management have outperformed MBA run companies many times over. The lesson here is: build a great product and the rest will follow in time. I have the stats to back this claim over a 50 year period (study done at MIT comparing MBA-run companies to engineer-run companies).
Yes, I don't want to ever again create a business plan and pitch to VC's based on the growth curve of the Internet. What a f*ing joke. But that's my mistake.
Just to know, can you point to the references backing this assertion:
"Historically, companies that had product experts (engineers) in management have outperformed MBA run companies many times over."
This was also published in another journal there. I'll post to this later. Bare with me!
I'll have to make a call to Germany on Monday morning - I don't have the paper anymore! I thought it would be an openly accessible PDF on their website.
I doubt anyone, least of all the CEO or his wife, would disagree with you. But their failure is instructive, and telling the story of their failure takes courage.
sensationalist reporting
There was nothing sensationalist about this article.
Why doesn't he believe in the strength of his product? If it's good, people will buy.
I'm sure he did believe in his product. But to think that you just set a new kind of beverage on a few shelves and then let the product quality take care of all of your sales, marketing, and brand-building for you is incredibly naive. Apple's products get a lot of acclaim, yet Apple still spends a fortune on advertising and on its distribution outlets.
He has not created any new knowledge on how to make beverages
Whether he has or hasn't is not evident one way or another from the article.
growing big fast
Economies of scale are present in beverage manufacturing just as they are in online retailing, search engines, and social networking. So all of your objections to his high-growth strategy also apply to Amazon, Google, eBay, Facebook, etc. But this guy is an easier target for you given the outcome.
young people
He did a great service to young people by replacing all of the crap chemical-laden sodas sold in California schools with his 100% juice alternative.
I don't want to ever again create a business plan and pitch to VC's based on the growth curve of the Internet
The Internet will remain the best bet for growth in the world economy for generations to come. Choosing not to leverage that will only hurt your future business prospects.
There is something odd about the glossy way business mags display entrepreneurs as heroes and even more when they are tragic. It's part of the same hype culture that I despise.
Growth Businesses
Google is a technology and product breakthrough - Pagerank, GFS, BigTable, MapReduce, AdWords, Server Design etc. Amazon - Cloud Computing, Recommendation Engine. Facebook - Social Graph. These are deserving growth businesses that have built out a true market niche. I don't see the beverage market in that same category.
Knowledge, Young People, Jobs
Building a beverage like this is not like hiring and training Master Brewers from Weihenstephan in Bavaria or red wine experts from Bordeaux. Packaging juice bottles is a minimum wage job like any other. I don't see the armies of new employees that will be created in this market segment.