the main difference is that the diagram is 2D, and molecules are usualy 3D.
the main difference is that the diagram is 2D, and molecules are usualy 3D.
In the two variants on the right, their edges seem to be curling upward making a bowl shape. Their edges are also brighter, which perhaps means they are closer to the probe than parts that are farther away. Additionally, the hexagons are also not all the same shape. I assume that's due to the curling.
I would be interested to know if my interpretation of the image is correct, or if the molecule is really flat and what I'm seeing is an artifact.
The trouble with all of this is the "picture" is not an actual picture-made-with-photons picture, but a visualization via computer. That isn't to say it's a poor reflection on reality, but that the limitations of the techniques should be accounted for. In this case, the electron density of the overall molecule is being measured. The brighter signals correspond to an increase in local electron density.
In such chemical structures as these, the aromaticity [1] is the main force at play. Without getting too technical, the brighter regions are those with increased electron density. (See figure 4 at the IBM Zurich page on pentacene [2])
The hexagons (and square and pentagons) in fact do not have idealized geometry, but not due to any curling. The unique environment of each carbon is more at play. Symmetry plays a large role; imagine a symmetric vs. unsymmetrical tug-of-war between the carbons with the electrons as the rope. The left hand side and lower right have a dihedral mirror plane, simplifying the density somewhat, where the upper right has a more muddled situation.
Getting back to the flatness, the target molecule is 'mounted' on a suitably uniform surface, such that only one side is being scanned/read by the probe. In a vacuum, the tug of war in the Z direction (into the plane) will cancel out between the +Z and -Z vectors, giving a 'flat' molecule. (Depending on your point of view, either because of this or due to this, each of these molecules has a mirror plane in the plane of the molecule, bisecting each atom.)
Setting all that aside, the entire process is really #$%*& cool, particularly to a chemist. (Yes, those crazy textbook pictures are often reflected in reality. If only the different atoms were color coded, though!)
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aromaticity [2] http://www.zurich.ibm.com/st/atomic_manipulation/pentacene.h...
It seemed to me that it was more directly measuring the bond energies, which, of course, is related to electron density.
I probably learned it in some chem course, and later forgot as all my math and science got applied to business :(
Electron orbitals can overlap in different ways depending on the geometry of the atom and its electronics. See this for a picture: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Benzene_Representations.sv... So, the electrons in a benzene ring really form more of a cloud around the entire ring. You'd expect this to pull the atoms into a perfect circle with the carbon atoms all being equidistance from each other, all else being equal.
However, each carbon atom also has a hydrogen atom attached to it. So now you have a sort of a circle with 6 "strings" attached at points equidistant around the circle all pulling outward, perpendicular to the circle.
Imagine a perfectly circular piece of string with 6 strings attached equidistantly around the circle. You apply an equal force perpendicular to the surface of the circle.
Hopefully you can see how this would result in the original circular string being "deformed" into a hexagon.
It's a far leap from there to say why hexagons are "so common in nature." Are they? Relative to what? I don't know that any of this has anything to do with the shape of that storm you linked to.
I was thinking of things (compared to other geometric shapes) like the storm, honey bee cells (honeycombs), basalt columns [1], turtle shells (although irregular), and a common snowflake shape.
But a tile of circles isn't so fortunate. Of all the possible tilings, the hexagonal tiling holds up the best precisely because it's the densest sphere packing in the plane.
Other arrangements might appear, but over the course of time you're more likely to see hexagonal tilings since those are the ones that best survive external forces.
It has to do with the bond angles in water molecules. The bond angles are, in turn, determined by quantum mechanical wave functions. These quantum mechanical wave functions apply to all of chemistry, including benzene rings. So the shapes of snowflakes and the shapes of benzene rings are not totally independent events.
As for nature in general, you could probably come up with a convincing argument that boils down to: 6 is a nice round number. It has 2 and 3 as factors.
In chemistry, or in nature? five membered rings show up all over the place, both aromatic and otherwise. Granted, cyclobutyl (4 member, square) and cyclopropyl (3 membered, triangle) suffer from ring strain and are uncommon, but 5, 6, 7, (or higher) rings show up all over the place.
Examples off the top of my head are the cyclopentadienyl ion pervasive in inorganic chemistry (see ferrocene, et al) and amino acids tryptophan, tyrosine, histidine, and phynylalanine all feature cyclic aromatics 5 and 6 membered, as well as proline with a non-aromatic 5 member ring.
The takeaway point is that although ring-strain (having non ideal angles (120 or 109.5 degrees)) increases the internal energy of the molecule (destabilizing it), other factors, such as aromaticity, which decrease internal energy (stabilizing it) may balance or exceed the ring-strain, still giving a stabilized, if non-ideal geometry.
(But yeah, 3, 4 membered rings, ugh. Look up platonic alkanes for some really crazy strain angles.)