The embarrassment of American broadband
macworld.com
macworld.com
I read 'subscriber' as 'person in the household that pays the bill'... multiple people may be using that account.
If you click through to the OECD numbers, you'll find the following:
Rank Country Subscribers/100 people
1 Denmark 36.7
6 Sweden 32.3
7 S. Korea 31.2
10 Canada 27.9
15 United States 25.0
17 Japan 23.0
20 Spain 19.8
30 Mexico 4.7
=========================
OECD Average 21.3
Not near as alarmist as he makes it seem.I agree that our slow speeds are embarassing, but statements like:
"But it’s pathetic that roughly three-quarters of the people in this country don’t have broadband Internet service."
are disingenuous at best, and, as you'll see in the next table, blatantly false.
The fact is that "subscribers per 100 people" is always going to be higher in countries with smaller households (Smaller households mean more households per 100 people, which means more subscribers per 100 people).
More useful statistics would be "households with broadband access", which thankfully is also provided by the OECD data:
Rank Country % households with broadband
1 S. Korea 94.1 (includes 3G)
4 Denmark 69.5
5 Japan 67.6 (includes 3G, but only when tethered)
7 Sweden 66.6
8 Canada 64.0
14 United States 50.8
20 Spain 39.2
30 Mexico 6.1
=========================
OECD Average 48.2
Also, before the obligatory "but the US is different, we are spread out" comment comes, the OECD has data on that too. There is a positive correlation between subscribers and population density, but it is 0.22, so not overwhelming. While correlation (or lack thereof) does not imply (or deny) causation, I'd imagine factors like regulation have much more to do with it than geography. 1) Thank you for being logical and data driven
2) Damn you for being logical and data driven
I'm a firm believer that necessity is the mother of invention. I also believe that necessity is only proven by crisis. Even if we had the world's greatest broadband infrastructure, I'd rather everyone think we were having an internet drought of biblical proportions. It would certainly step up the pace of innovation and encourage modernized legislation.Romania was smart/lucky because people started their own micro-ISPs (Block/Neighborhood Networks) with 50 to 3000 customers each. Buying from bigger ISPs very powerful connections and selling it to more users that shared that connection. Thanks to competition, it brought the prices down a lot and even the big ISP had to adjust.
Edit: There is a side effect like having this http://www.roconsulboston.com/Media/Artists/DDBuchJly08/Wire... on almost all streets in Bucharest, but I find the benefits much higher. Also Wireless Internet is free in pubs/bistros/coffee houses that provide this service here.
Yes, I realize the story is as much about penetration as it is raw speed. But really, once you have felt ~100mbits, it's just painful to hear people talking about 256k as 'Broadband'.
As far as I understand it, the broadband is pretty much monopolized in the US, while it's pretty competetive over here. Perhaps the cellular providers can provide some competition? It's happening here already, with for instance 3 providing 3G-only services for use with your laptop.
I don't think Canada, Australia or the UK have terribly good broadband options either.
The sun never sets on the British Empire, remember all that crap they used to say before it set on them for good?
Sigh.
There does exist a level of broadband at which point it's not worth increasing the level of broadband any more. Does anybody make the argument that we are below that level?
What are we going to do with more broadband? Watch movies at higher resolution? What a life-changing experience that will be!
There are definitely more interesting ways in which higher amounts of broadband could change the way we use the Internet, but right now the limiting factor is imagination and distribution channels, not bandwidth.
I paid an extra $14, for a total of about $80 last month, because I downloaded an extra 7GB over my 60GB monthly cap.
Mmm nothing like markets with zero competition.
Edit: Mine is 20MBbit down, 2MBit up.
In 2000-01 I briefly had a relatively modest (2mbit/sec) DSL line from a local mini-ISP with crazy fast ping times and DNS on steroids: nearly everything on the Internet would load under half a second.
That mini-ISP got acquired and disappeared, and my internet experience has been deteriorating ever since: my guaranteed 6mbit/sec connection allows me to I download hundreds of front pages of HN per second, yet I wait for up to 10 seconds sometimes to load just one, and google maps always gets stuck at one or two map fragments when I look something up.
I'm glad the current administration is committed to a broadband plan for the US, although I'm worried that the FCC has set it sights far too low. Personally, I'm OK with some taxes going towards this; Broadband is nowadays as important as a well-functioning road system. It seems to me that the poorer or less economically developed parts of the US would derive big long-term economic benefits.
http://www.fcc.gov/broadband is the central FCC page for the electronic superhighway and related policies. Though very dull looking, there's a lot of substance at the links on the left.
$5.00 for two hours!? What!?
1 hour of wifi access from "the cloud" is £4.50 (approx $6.60) - http://www.thecloud.net/pay-as-you-go