How Google Authorship and Penguin have killed our traffic – follow-up
jitbit.com
jitbit.com
These COULD potentially hurt you, but I doubt it. That would mean all forum software links in the footers were doing more harm than good. Forum software websites like phpBB, vBulletin etc are doing just fine. Furthermore, your install-base and incoming links should grow slowly over time and Google will recognize that as a natural kind of thing. Therefore, I would cross that off your list of reasons.
Your main reason for being hit by Penguin are bad SEO practices. Never buy links for SEO. You may benefit from these links today, but 3 years down the road Google might catch on. (As you just realized)
If you do purchase links, make sure to nofollow them and point the user to an actionable page. Such as purchasing your software or signing up for a newsletter. The goal here won't be for SEO purposes, but for advertising.
Would something like that be penalized with Penguin? Honestly, not sure if that counts as "Gray Hat" or not.
I do not think those links would be penalized with Penguin for the same reasons I previously mentioned.
Is it a cheesy way to get links? Probably. But you should be fine.
The writer doesn't know for certain those things were hurting him, but out of fear their whole marketing strategy changed and now they are going about the business of getting links taken down.
Now, you could argue that they should have been more thoughtful about their SEO efforts in the first place, but consider how deeply dysfunctional it is that webmasters are so afraid of Google and Matt Cutts that they are begging each other to take down links they paid for in the first place.
There is no scientific proof that any of these links had anything to do with them ranking well or badly or changing their CTR or anything, the author is just assuming it's these things that hurt their Google traffic.
Google's ranking policies are now the equivalent of the webmaster boogie man.
They where penalised hard by google - and they had to grovel to get back in.
Pity that getting burned once didn't make them take our advice on SEO.
Wait, how is that dysfunctional? "should have been more thoughtful about their SEO efforts in the first place" implies at least a likelihood that they would want to rescind their earlier actions, which is what they're doing. That seems...functional.
I mean, living in fear of only somewhat specified rules likely has other consequences that discourage good behavior in other ways, but the specifics you describe seems like what you'd want to happen[1].
* Bad Links bought by their SEO contractor
* "Grey Hat" link buying
I stand by my tl;dr - they lost traffic due to bad SEO. I never said it was their fault, but it's certainly not Google's.
Neither did the author.
1: ...
2: ...
3: Find links from non-English pages - this one is obvious
Isn't the internet an international thing? If Slovenians like a site, shouldn't that help, not hurt?
Not to mention the facepalm-chuckle this gives me, this accounts for two of your three reasons. Why wasn't it included in the title? In fact, the title's assertion is not supported at all by the post.