Hacker News Reader

Comment by inerte | Hacker News Reader

Horrible type of humor, IMHO.

I am known for making some hardcore jokes, but I try not to laugh, and profit, from others people horrors. Just like I want others to not laugh from mine.

And no, I won't "lighten up and laugh, life is funny". It's like these authors never went into a painful experience. I am pretty sure their grandfathers died of cancer, or something like that. A similar slow destroying, soul crushing process. I wonder how they would feel if random people started making jokes about cancer.

But hey, we're just little monkeys, living in a sphere of indifference.

View on HN

What if he were a more traditional comedian, and gallows humor was how he coped with, and helped others cope with, a situation that many people find scary and beyond their control?

Would you still feel justified in condemning him for profiting "from other people's horrors"?

I think gallows humor makes sense sometimes. For example, in the case of terrorism, which we really have no way to prevent and can just as easily hit the rich as it can the poor. Hence, the jokes that we hear nightly about Osama, etc.

But the people who buy these shirts or make these games probably won't have to deal with swine flu (or at least die from it), because they likely have good healthcare and their nations are relatively rich with infrastructures that can accommodate a large percentage of their populations becoming sick at once. I don't think they're in a position to mock the disease.

On the other hand, I'm fine the Mexicans who are sprucing up their face masks with funny mustaches as people are dying around them. They're living it. The guys looking to get their startup a few more ad impressions? Not so much.

> But the people who buy these shirts or make these games probably won't have to deal with swine flu

You might consider that people's fears about most dangers are far out of proportion to the actual probability of their encountering them.

Mexicans actually play Swinefighter more than any other country.

It is a serious subject, we made the game in a way that was sensitive to that and avoided mocking the victims but was intended to give some amusement. People on the whole enjoy it on twitter etc.

Edit: we also have no ads runing currently

I think you're doing the "what aboutery" discussed some time ago. These people are not traditional comedians dealing with their own pains using humour, and making life brighter. It's a couple kids here and there selling "funny" t-shirts.

It's not a therapeutical way for them to deal with the problem. It's for a quick buck.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com