[edit]Link for reference, if anyone missed that particular news: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-14/u-s-agencies-said-t... [/edit]
[edit]Link for reference, if anyone missed that particular news: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-06-14/u-s-agencies-said-t... [/edit]
NSA does not need Microsoft's help to break into Windows boxes.
What's wrong with speculating that the Microsoft Bug Bounty is an NSA-influenced plot to funnel zero-day to the government is that that's a stupid conspiracy theory. It's elaborate and complicated in ways that the NSA doesn't need to deal with. It also casts aspersions on the people at Microsoft --- who are actual people who you can actually talk to --- who worked very hard to make this program happen after Microsoft spent years being criticized for not doing this.
From this and other assertions made in the Bloomberg piece, it seems very fair not to read this as conventional patch management, but as a special arrangement with intelligence agencies. And to read this as, yes, from time to time Microsoft's help does get the NSA into Windows boxes.
Now, we all know that tech reporting often leaves something to be desired. If you're saying the officials were wrong or quoted out of context, then that's fine. But it's not reasonable to dismiss this out of hand as some outlandish Alex Jonesian conspiracy theory.
BTW, obviously I'm not saying that Microsoft's bug bounty program is an NSA plot. It's a good program that every major company should have. I'm also not saying that they don't share bugs with other partners ahead of time, they obviously do. Just that from what the sources in this article (which again, did not originally appear on infowars.com) say, Microsoft does have a special arrangement with intelligence agencies and from time to time has shared bugs knowing they might be exploited by said agencies. The bug bounty program could find the sort of bugs that would (incidentally) be shared as part of this arrangement.