That's specious reasoning, there are many BTC->USD exchanges and the IRS could easily compel you to exchange your currency for USD.
Edit: I stand corrected by the comments below.
I think the rules for commodities and currencies are likely different. Regardless, bitcoin is clearly one of those two and you don't get to avoid the IRS by only dealing in commodities.
(Note: this is known as a "method of accounting" in tax parlance.)