I dont know: you see he does have a point about choosing what to block. Given a choice I would allow ads to be displayed on noscript sites because:

a) I trust the site owner not to show me crap b) It is his revenue stream and I am willing to support causes I like

The best solution was for ABP to fix the flaws that allowed the ads on noscript to slip through the filters. Instead the maintainer chose to rope Ares2 into updating Easylist2 to deliberately target the site.

Whatever the motives or the arguments for each side that smacks of the "wrong way to do it" to me :)