Cato Comments on TSA Body Scanners
cato.org
cato.org
The UCSF letter of concern about the penetrative depth of the radiation (here, weirdly, deeper penetration is better) was refuted by the scanner's inventor, who said the doctors confused two different metrics (radiation dose metrics, which were deep, and imaging depth, which was as designed shallow). But even if you believe the UCSF letter; what banana multiple are we talking about here? A 10x error in the amount of radiation the original backscatter machines generated would still work out to just tens of bananas.
Moreover, the flight itself totally dominates the radiation cost of an airline trip. NYC to LA is 10's of microsieverts; multiple hundreds of bananas.
The problem with backscatter machines isn't that they're unhealthy, and people shouldn't twist science into knots to make political points. Be careful about cheering for our side using a tactic that can easily be used against us in the future.
The problem with the machine is that they're strip searches, and administrative strip searches are unreasonable.
Shallow isnt a problem?
Except the flight has a real benefit and scanning has almost no benefit. So calculate the cost-benefit between the cost of radiation for flying vs. the scanners.
We should be up in arms about the strip search itself.
At least with the backscatter machines I could be upset that the TSA was taking nude photos of my daughter that I could be realistically pissed about.
I still find it morally reprehensible, but that alone is harder to argue when so many other Americans just don't care.
Of course not, it is a cost. The point is that it doesn't matter how little the additional radiation is, only that it is additional pointless radiation. Save lives by taking all of the money wasted on violating our dignity with the nudie scanners and put it towards extra shielding.
In particular, the radiation from the decay of potassium in bananas is different particles, wavelengths, and energy than that of X-Rays, so using "banana equivalents" to talk about X-Rays is obfuscatory oversimplification.
(Fun thread on the RadSafe list about banana dose equivalents: http://health.phys.iit.edu/archives/2011-March/031410.html)
The specific energy, delivery, and timing could all be worse or better. Given non-linear effects like hormesis, the scanners (or flight) might even be good, at some levels, then turn bad.
It ought to be studied, with the actual devices in real-world scenarios, and to the same level of scrutiny of medical radiation devices -- which have themselves killed people when misunderstood or misprogrammed. Instead, the TSA's use seems rushed through a different less-accountable process, with a bunch of hand-waving "this is kinda like that" reassurances.
This is so easily and quickly forgotten. :(
I would even extend that to "any side" - don't have principles simply because that in itself is expedient to a cause; you should do it for a deeper reason.
This assumes that the machines always work as they should.
TSA’s nude body scanning policies probably cause more deaths than they prevent. For this reason, we recommend in our comment that the TSA suspend the current policies, commence a new rulemaking, and implement a rational policy resulting from an examination of all issues on the public record.
Cato's 50 page comment. If you want any ideas. http://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/wp-content/uploads/...
http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-20022541-281.html
The administration's defense of the controversial machines, which use X-rays to perform what critics have dubbed naked strip searches, has "many misconceptions, and we will write a careful answer pointing out their errors," said John Sedat, a UCSF professor of biochemistry and biophysics and member of the National Academy of Sciences...
Their letter to Holdren said "it appears that real independent safety data do not exist." In addition, the authors say: "There has not been sufficient review of the intermediate and long-term effects of radiation exposure associated with airport scanners. There is good reason to believe that these scanners will increase the risk of cancer to children and other vulnerable populations."
Way to make it seem like the TSA has a nude body scan porno problem, Cato. Love that sort of thing.