"Judges generally confer only with government lawyers, and out of public view. Yet the judges have the power to interpret the Constitution and set long-lasting and far-reaching precedent on matters involving Americans’ rights to privacy and due process under the Fourth Amendment. And this fast-growing body of law is almost entirely out of view of legal scholars and the public. Most Americans do not have access to the judiciary’s full interpretation of the Constitution on matters of surveillance, search and seizure when it comes to snooping for terrorist plots — and are limited in their ability to challenge it"
"The judges that are assigned to this court are judges that are not likely to rock the boat,” said Nancy Gertner, a former federal judge from Massachusetts who teaches at Harvard Law School. Gertner, a former defense and civil rights lawyer named to the bench by Democrat Bill Clinton, added: “All of the structural pressures that keep a judge independent are missing there. It’s one-sided, secret, and the judges are chosen in a selection process by one man."
I've never been particularly fond of Marbury vs. Madison (I'm not sure it was wise to trash the Common Law system), but if this is true it's potentially in violation of that precedent, by, apparently, creating a rival supreme court, whose rulings are secret and which is stacked with yes-men by the executive.
P.S. This story has restored some of my faith in WAPO, which has been questioned by some of their actions in this story.