White House presses Russia to expel Snowden; sharp words for China
reuters.com
reuters.com
This kind of logic baffles me.
Most people are not hypocritical about principles they care deeply about, so it's fair to ask whether Internet freedom is itself the principle Snowden is concerned about (in which case, why allow for hypocrisy), or whether it's something else entirely. After all one thing people pretty much can't say about RMS is that the man doesn't stand behind his principles. (edited to fix verb tense)
Now I'm even starting to be confused about what precisely Snowden's motives are. On some topics he talks about how people in general have rights, then he starts talking about how he's worried about America and Americans specifically as if he's a patriot that doesn't care as much about the rest of the world. He talks about violating 4th Amendment rights and needing warrants and then says that you can't get a fair trial in America.
I've actually been more aggravated by this argument coming from the "other side". When it was announced that Snowden was heading for Ecuador, Human Rights Watch (among others) began posting to Twitter about Ecuador's terrible record with press freedom (shortened: there is freedom of the press in Ecuador as long as the press isn't criticizing the Correa administration). People immediate set about slamming HRW for drawing attention to Ecuador's problems without accounting for every problem in the US.
Same problem: if Ecuador is jailing journalists, seizing their property, or even torturing and killing them --- all things alleged by human rights groups about Ecuador --- that's a problem regardless of what the US is doing.
Similarly, if the NSA is unlawfully stretching the FISA process to surveil Americans, that's something worth publicizing no matter how many journalists Russia and China kill.
I have a lot of the same problems with the Snowden story that you do, but I was disheartened to read that Carney had made that argument today.
I think the one big thing I can't get around is the cognitive dissonance of wanting more of the 'rule of law' around things like FISA but then globe-hopping because the 'rule of law' has become inconvenient. Certainly where the law is not being followed that should be fixed, and good on Snowden for noting that. But how can it be true that the same judiciary that issues warrants under the 4th Amendment cannot be trusted to run a fair trial? If the judiciary is untrustworthy then adding warrants to more spots in the NSA cannot fix the issue. So is that what Snowden wants, or does he want to prevent the government from even having the ability to monitor communications, even with a warrant?
Similarly, if Snowden is such a patriot I can't believe that he has putting himself, his brain, and all the TS that he's carrying or has access to within 100 miles of Russia. He's potentially one $5 wrench away from spilling a lot of TS, voluntarily or otherwise, to people who are not as kind as Assange and Greenwald.
I just don't know what to think about him anymore, and I think that's what is bugging me more than anything.
Regardless: I don't think his motives should have much to do with how the law treats him, which makes the concern over which countries he's choosing to visit even more of a sideshow.
I think most rational observers understand why Snowden is picking the countries he's picking; he's choosing the large, easily reached countries with the weakest ties to US law enforcement. It's disingenuous to pretend that his arrival in Moscow is a commentary on Russian civil rights.
How far along the "normal to crazy conspiracy theory" line would it be to question whether, if people like Manning and Snowden can so easily leak this information, couldn't China already have got it themselves? I mean, if spying had reached that level... would we know about it?
The idea that Snowden has only chosen to rail against the unreasonable privacy violations of the country he's a citizen of, and most familiar with doesn't seem surprising or unreasonable to me. The argument that if he hasn't put similar energies into calling out every other nation that finds itself in violation of these ideals, then he must be lying about his motivation is absurd.
Also, he doesn't say 'you' can't get a fair trial in America, he says that he can't get a fair trial in America.
Just because he's not publicly admonishing these countries doesn't mean that he condones their behavior. Perhaps he's a pragmatist who knows better than to bite the hand the feeds. Or perhaps he is much more impassioned about freedom in the U.S., his native land, sold to him as a bastion of civil liberty, than about freedom in countries that he cares less about.
That seems pretty clear to me.
[1] http://www.cnn.com/2013/06/24/politics/nsa-leak/index.html
I studied global security & intelligence in college, and had a personality profiling class focusing on cases of american espionage. My two cents is coming pretty heavily from that.
I'll put it this way; can we all admit that the fact that Hong Kong must defer to the Communist government in Beijing was not accidental on Snowden's part?
He fled to Hong Kong, not mainland China. Having been in both places, I can assure you that HK doesn't have a great firewall and internet censors.
edit: or to reveal that the NSA listened to Medvedev's phone calls at the G8?
>His exposing of classified NSA activity suggests that his true motive throughout has been to injure the national security of the United States, not to advance Internet freedom and free speech
it was:
>His failures to criticize these regimes suggests that his true motive throughout has been to injure the national security of the United States, not to advance Internet freedom and free speech
Maybe Snowden's intention was to hurt the U.S.; I couldn't say. But it certainly doesn't follow logically from Snowden not admonishing other countries.
There seems to be a lot of double speak about THE LAW as being something universal. This seems to me to be mostly propaganda directed at Americans since foreign governments certainly understand the nuances of treaties, etc. I don't want to be too critical but it seems like the USA being one of the few countries to not accept the world court is ironic.
This seems to be the exact correct thing to say, though. Would you have preferred
<< we're following all the appropriate legal channels and working with various other countries to make sure the rule of AMERICAN law is observed" >>
?
I'd really rather they be saying the former and walking the walk.
We could very well have a case come down in the future that pulls a Roe v. Wade on electronic privacy and reads a broad protection of communications privacy into the Constitution. It would be an act of legislating by judicial fiat, but sometimes that is justified to address gaps in the Constitution. Maybe that would be a good thing. But in the meantime, it's hard for me to take seriously the idea that the government's dedication to the rule of law is undermined by a set of programs that seem to be explicitly designed to stay within the bounds of the law as it exists today.
Edit: Even the FISC itself thinks the programs are unconstitutional [2]. Now you may think the constitution itself is obsolete on these points, but there are perfectly valid methods of ratifying/updating that document other than to completely ignore it.
[1] http://www.aclu.org/national-security/aclu-files-lawsuit-cha...
[2] http://www.ibtimes.com/fisc-will-not-object-release-2011-cou...
As for the FISC opinion, we have no idea which programs it is referring to. We definitely need to get that opinion made public so that we can see.
There are two different things at play: are the NSA's activities Constitutional and is the NSA adhering to the rule of law? The latter is really about a good faith attempt to stay within the bounds of the law as it currently exists. To go back to my Roe v. Wade example, a complete ban on abortion is unconstitutional as of 1973. But does that meant that the legislatures that passed those bans in 1972 had no commitment to the rule of law?
I agree that the FISC opinion in question will be very enlightening.
Also, I agree that a "Roe v. Wade"-esque supreme court decision would provide a nice degree of finality to the issue, provided they agree with my position :P (kidding!). We were so close earlier this year to having some of these programs declared unconstitutional (5-4 decision) [1], maybe this time around we will be a little more fortunate. Or maybe I'm just naively optimistic.
Also, Rayiner, from the based on the well-educated substance of your posts and your profile I have to ask, are you a lawyer?
[1] http://www.aclu.org/national-security/supreme-court-dismisse...
My understanding of this basis is that the government contends that pure storage of data does not constitute a search (not that I accept this line of reasoning). However, in a legal system that takes intellectual property very seriously, in what sense does it not constitute a seizure?
1) The 4th amendment doesn't extend to non-U.S. persons. The prevailing view of the Constitution is that its scope is territorial. You have to have some connection to the U.S. to have rights and obligations under the Constitution. That means either living here, even if you're not a citizen, or being a citizen, even if you're living abroad. A lot of the NSA's procedures are concerned with making sure that it's data collection is limited to that likely to be with "non-U.S. persons."
2) The third party doctrine: by handing information over to Google, etc, you're purposefully exposing the information and can no longer claim that it's private in the same way the contents of your desk drawer are private. It is already established that bank records and telephone numbers you've dialed are not protected by the 4th amendment for this reason (https://ssd.eff.org/your-computer/govt/privacy).
I'm not sure the degree to which it has been established that the NSA is doing anything that requires treating pure data storage as not a search, but in any case why should the standard for what constitutes a search have any relation to copying under the copyright laws? The intent and purposes of the two regimes are totally different. Also, you have to be careful about whose data is being stored, because Constitutionally there is nothing wrong with them storing the data of non-U.S. persons).
This seems highly suspect; either they have to snoop on you to see if it's okay to snoop on you, and/or do some probabilistic mumbo-jumbo to guess at whether you're a foreigner.
> The third party doctrine: by handing information over to Google, etc, you're purposefully exposing the information
Doesn't basic encryption (HTTPS) imply an expectation of privacy? Also, assuming the tech companies aren't BSing us, it certainly seems like the data is being consumed against their will as well, so it's not necessarily a matter of Google selling search histories.
While I believe that NSA activities already violate the letter and spirit of the 4th Amendment, I absolutely support the idea that we should pass new legislation to protect our privacy rights in the Information Age from both state and corporate power, removing all ambiguity.
> why should the standard for what constitutes a search have any relation to copying under the copyright laws
There seems to be an interesting Catch-22 here: how can I claim ownership over my data without disclosing it? I could declare every email I send to be a copyrighted work, thus making it illegal to store without permission, yet doing so inherently divulges the information.
> Constitutionally there is nothing wrong with them storing the data of non-U.S. persons
There isn't, but there should be. The deeper moral issues notwithstanding, we're well on track to destroy our leadership in the global internet industry right now.
They have these amazing things called IP addresses that tell you what country traffic is coming from.
> Doesn't basic encryption (HTTPS) imply an expectation of privacy?
Privacy as against who? Even if you use HTTPS, you still expose the clear text to Google, Facebook, etc. I don't think it is an unreasonable interpretation of existing precedent, on the NSA's part, to argue that if random sysadmins at Google can access the data, then the government doesn't need a warrant to subpoena the data.
> Also, assuming the tech companies aren't BSing us, it certainly seems like the data is being consumed against their will as well, so it's not necessarily a matter of Google selling search histories.
It's not a matter of Google selling search histories. "Private" for the purposes of the 4th amendment means "inside your desk drawer" private, not just "not public." Bank records aren't public, your bank doesn't sell them, but they're not covered by the 4th amendment.
> There isn't, but there should be. The deeper moral issues notwithstanding, we're well on track to destroy our leadership in the global internet industry right now.
The Constitution determines the rights and obligations of Americans to each other and those on U.S. soil. It's not a vehicle for determining who we treat non-Americans, and should not be so. The country's foreign policy is a political issue, not a legal issue. Indeed, it would be a massive violation of the separation of powers for the courts to start policing how the U.S. treats foreigners, because foreign policy is the exclusive domain of the elected branches, especially the executive. This is by design, the framers intended the U.S. to "speak with one voice" with regards to the outside world.
If Americans want to spy on the rest of the world, it's not the courts' job to tell them that they can't. If that hurts American competitiveness in the internet industry, well that's an issue for political debate too.
I think as a practical matter the U.S. is far too dominant in software and online technology for NSA spying to be more than a blip, and it's not like other countries don't do it too.
I'd be embarrassed for our intelligence agencies if that's all they looked at. (a) Americans travel abroad, an American Skyping home should be completely covered under the 4th. (b) Foreign actors are perfectly capable of using proxies, either human or electronic.
> "Private" for the purposes of the 4th amendment means "inside your desk drawer" private, not just "not public."
If I mail a letter to Bob, it is private to both Bob and I. If I save a document to Google Docs over https, it is private to both Google and I. Assuming Google honors that privacy (big assumption, I know), how does that not qualify as "desk drawer private"?
> The Constitution determines the rights and obligations of Americans to each other and those on U.S. soil.
Absolutely; I'm not arguing a legal imperative not to spy indiscriminately on foreigners. I'm stating a moral imperative not to do so. There are ways in which I believe the current spying activity violates the Constitution as-is, and yet I also believe we need to new laws to safeguard the values of human liberty that the Constitution is meant to enshrine and defend, for all humans and not just citizens. (And yes, that includes restraints on corporate power in addition to government power.)
For meta-content that's held forever - I guess they say it's not private and thus they can keep it forever.
The UK is going through some kerfuffle around meta-data to allow it to be gathered and kept.
See, for example, the exemption in the UK version of the DMCA for people who are "studying cryptography" (http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/section/296ZA)
I should just link to UK RIPA (http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/23/contents), especially this bit: (http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/23/section/42) but actually all of it.
RIPA is interesting. I genuinely don't care about GCHQ caching content for three days and keeping meta data for 30 days. That has no impact on my life. I do care about the abuses that other government departments (usually local government) has carried out using powers under RIPA.
Some edits, but I forget to label them! Sorry.
I think the more accurate question would be "So how does that undermine the government's credibility?" The "with regards to the rule of law" part is more or less irrelevant when dealing with international politics.
For several years now the United States and the UK have been warning about Chinese hacking/spying/electronic espionage. Now the US has been exposed to having conducted the same operations they accused China of, on a possibly even greater scale.
Obviously this has damaged their credibility, and is why they are so angry.