James Klapper: Yes I Lied To Congress, But Here's Why
businessinsider.com
businessinsider.com
An easy to understand question.
> "No, sir," Clapper replied.
An easy to understand answer.
> In the letter to Feinstein, Clapper explained the late addition to his original statement by saying that he realized Wyden was referring to collection of metadata — not content collection. Clapper said he thought Wyden was referring to Section 702 of the Federal Intelligence Surveillance Act, which permits the NSA to collect information on certain people outside of the United States — not the domestic data collection allowed under Section 215 of the Patriot Act.
WTF?
If the meeting is secret he should answer truthfully. If it's public he should decline to answer. What he shouldn't do is give a simple answer to a simple question and then justify the lie with a bunch of nonsense about context.
> "That said, I realized later that Senator Wyden was asking about section 215 metadata"
No. It is very clear that the senator was asking about "any data at all".
> "This is unbelievable on a variety of levels. First off, as Wyden made clear, his office had sent Clapper the question a day before the hearing so that he knew the question was coming. To argue that he was confused about the question is quite unbelievable. Furthermore, Senator Wyden claimed that: "after the hearing was over my staff and I gave his office a chance to amend his answer." Clapper now says that his staff "acknowledged the error to Senator Wyden soon after the hearing," but if that's the case, it doesn't appear that anyone else seems to know about this. Furthermore, if this were true, then wouldn't Clapper have said this back in early June when people first started asking about those statements? But he did not. This sounds like after-the-fact rationalizations for lying to Congress and being called on it. "
https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130701/12494623683/james...