To clean the air, Dutch scientists invent pavement that eats smog
latimes.com
latimes.com
There are ~2.5 million miles of highways in the United States, for the sake of easier math and a lack of statistics let us assume that this length of pavement is responsible for all of the vehicular nitrous oxide emissions.
Transportation contributes 30% of total NOx emissions [2]. Lets assume that the average highway is 4 lanes wide, giving a width of 62 feet.
Surface area = 2.5 million miles * 62 feet = 29 356 square miles.
The authors add 2.67 g per square meter of C-doped TiO2 (which has a lowball estimated cost of ~$750 per metric ton.)
This gives us 203 000 tonnes or ~$150 million. This has to be applied 3x a year (at least) to maintain ~%60 of maximal effectiveness of the TiO2 (20%) over the year.
A generous estimate is that it is sunny ~1/3 of the time.
So to bring it all together, $450 million of raw materials would result in a (1/3 * 60% * 20% * 30%) 1.18% reduction in NOx levels.
[1] Original Article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2013.02.012 (behind a paywall) [2] http://epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/gases/n2o.html
Edit: Updated math, I used the wrong percentage of the contribution of motor vehicle traffic, the correct figure is 30%, nevertheless the conclusion that this would be a colossal waste of money still stands.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Titanium_dioxide#Photocatalyst
[2] http://www.italcementigroup.com/NR/rdonlyres/1F30E487-C0A2-4...
[3] http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1...
[4] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304389413...
Can you provide a reference? Did I link to the wrong paper? That's an important detail and it's not in the article.
much more effective than regular TiO2
How much more effective? The study done by Italcementi in 2002-2003 (admittedly not very trustworthy since it's done by the company that makes the product) has numbers comparable to the Eindhoven study.
I'm not sure if you can get past the paywall but:
Section 2, paragraph 4, last sentence. "Carbon doped TiO2 from Kronos International was used."
How much more effective?
It varies from 2x-10x depending on the reaction conditions. Here is a paper that shows 2x-4x based on a relatively primitive doping technique.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apcatb.2007.09.046
Italcementi
Their TX Active may or may not be carbon doped, I couldn't find a straight answer on their website. Self-cleaning TiO2 is almost certainly doped (Ag or SiO2).
Observe: (1) The further you go from nature, the more problems you cause yourself. (2) Concrete industry is one of the greatest polluters in the world. (3) The impermeable nature of concrete is at once its weakness; by attempting to block nature's course, it ensures both its own destruction and engenders other problems such as flash floods. (4) Given the above, why make a new concrete to 'improve' upon nature? Nature cannot be improved upon. Because there is only one Way. (5) The Way that can be written is not the Way.
Smog-eating concrete isn't improving upon nature, it's improving upon not-nature (which concrete clearly is according to points 2 and 3), thus bringing it back closer to nature, and reducing the number of problems you cause yourself, per 1. So, if you must build a Way, at least build it out of smog-eating concrete.
There is some parallel here in conventional computing wisdom: measure twice cut once dictates that, given limited time, you're better off thinking a course of action out before investing effort in creating something requiring an ongoing investment of effort.
Thus, if the scope for this type of invention is environmental quality, why not consider overall energy use and knock-on effects as part of your evaluation?
Well you got that part right.
I found the flaw in your argument! It's there, it's there! It's that premise!
What do I win?