It is well worth a read for an extremely well argued, and informed, opinion from the other side.
It is well worth a read for an extremely well argued, and informed, opinion from the other side.
He also says some questionable stuff. Like this:
>We asked for this. We did so because we measured the reach and possible overreach of law enforcement against the risks of terrorism and made a conscious choice.
Everyone in Congress who read the Patriot Act before voting on it voted against it. So no, we didn't. We had a gut reaction to a tragedy, somebody pulled a defense contractor wish list out of a drawer and they passed it in a moment of sorrow and anger. The country is only now starting to reach the point that we can have a rational conversation about anti-terrorism without the pain of a recent tragedy allowing self-interested warmongers to goad us into an overreaction, and it's time that we seriously reevaluate what we allow the government to do on our behalf.
And I'm reminded of what John Oliver said hosting the Daily Show when all of this came out: "I think you're misunderstanding the perceived problem here, Mr. President. No one is saying you broke any laws. We're just saying it's a little bit weird that you didn't have to."
Everybody believed that is actually what the intelligence services do, and applauded.
With that context in mind, I still think it's worth reading Simon's original post that you linked to. He's a very articulate writer who has clearly shown he's no puppet of the establishment through his work on shows like The Wire.
[1]http://davidsimon.com/nsa-and-fisa-commentary-calling-it/
I'm all for brief and limited surveillance authorized by warrants tied to a specific case (e.g. his Baltimore example), what I find unacceptable about PRISM is exactly the thing Simon glosses over as irrelevant, its scale: virtually unlimited in both duration and scope.
Additionally, an easy abuse of the system would be to look for people doing embarrassing things and link it to those people for later political blackmail or other neutralization. We don't have evidence that this has occurred, but I think it was indicated that the audit trails and other civil liberties protections were not implemented well in these systems.