Because if we are going to argue policy and common law, than we also have restrictions that don't appear in the text, but appeared in common law, as well.
Because if we are going to argue policy and common law, than we also have restrictions that don't appear in the text, but appeared in common law, as well.
There is no danger in erring on the side of too much liberty. Parent errs on side of denying of liberty already clearly enumerated.
As we've both gone through, the 4th amendment can't be viewed in a vacuum, or else it would be nonsensical.
So saying "i don't see where the literal text of the 4th amendment says that" doesn't seem to me a complete and total argument.
For example, it literally says nothing about anything but papers, persons, houses, and effects. None of this explicitly covers phone calls, or even e-mail. You have to argue by analogy or inclusion in today's equivalent of papers or effects
It also only prevents unreasonable searches and seizures, and there is an argument to be made that "special needs" or "overriding public danger" make the searches not unreasonable. I don't personally buy it, but ...
As you mention, there is also historical context on all sides to consider.
That is in fact, exactly my point. Saying "it ain't in the text" is even far past what textualism adherents do, and i'd venture to guess, would not make for a very useful statute construction philosophy.