I'm not saying it's OK, far from it. It's just that there's nothing new in this story.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5884858
Yes, it has been mentioned previously.
UK media is under a notice from the Department of Defence - a D notice - which is an informal arrangement where the DoD asks media not to report things which they think are strategically important, and the media agrees.
The Official Secrets Act is the legal framework for secrets. People "Sign the Official Secrets Act", but all that means is that they've been made aware that the act exists. You can be prosecuted for revealing secrets even if you haven't signed the act. (I seem to remember some protesters being prosecuted for publishing photographs of missile transport in the 80s?)
So, while the D notice system is informal and is not a prohibition I guess it's a warning about what is considered really important. There's interesting discussion about why a free media pays any attention at all to D Notices.
I think the D Notice for the full take system is an abuse of the D Notice system. (Location of troops during war, for example.)
(BTW that was a bad joke, for those who take tings seriously)
Tell you what this does mean though, our parliament has been lied too, which is supposed to be a big deal. But I guess all the opposition MP's are too worried that GCHQ know all the porn sites they visit. Lets face it, we all have something to hide, and chances are now that the gov knows about it, or can do with the right Db query.
"Tempora is the first 'I save everything' approach ('full take') in the intelligence world. It sucks in all data, no matter what it is, and which rights are violated by it"
The other systems have always been given some degree of plausible deniability by government doing some hand-waving and suggesting that they have controlled methods by which wiretaps are only placed on specific targets, for specific reasons, etc. etc.
When you start saving everything, especially stuff that you know you are not supposed to, you are violating UK law (Human Rights Act of 1988) as well as international law (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive)
Trying to pass this off as nothing to be concerned about means that you are not paying attention, or don't care.
Tempora isn't new news either [1].
> Trying to pass this off as nothing to be concerned about means that you are not paying attention, or don't care.
Did you even read my comment? Where did I say nothing to be concerned about?
I'm pretty sure that's media sensationalism - were they get quite ahead of the facts and details, and spin the headlines. Or worse, leave out the logic of it all and replace it with something else - the narative the reader wants to believe (ex: they are gathering data on me to be used against me).
Not only does it take time to process the data, but an operational window (of that data) needs to be maintained for the next couple of days - were that data can be cross-referenced with the new feed and possibly be mind and connected to new events as they are unfolding. As otherwise it's useless.
The data is filtered for specific targets, or on specific triggers, or graph data, which is then kept. The rest (like 99.9999995% or more) is just noise that has no use to intelligence gathering - and I don't see why anyone would store it - or would want to store it.
Once the people start creating new laws, and getting them passed, we'll win. Currently, politicians hand us laws that are drafted by corporations & lobbyists, then we simply react.
It's all about us being more assertive.
We already have the bill of rights. Creating new laws won't help us. It's too late for that. Maybe repealing some laws and executive orders might help... but what we're seeing is the symptom of something bigger than governments.
We need to see the cage and step out of it. Educating ourselves and honing our common sense will help us. Becoming self sufficient will help us.
Because the way the bill of rights is treated now is farcical.
You sound frustrated, as a lot of people are these days. Is it helping to be reactive to all of the things you mentioned? What if you instead were proactive, and defined a new law & helped promote it?
For instance, you mentioned illegal wars. What if we created a new law, that required a popular vote, yearly, to continue any war? That would be awesome, right? :)
Let's write some good laws, and get them passed.
You're still in the denial stage. I've been there. You've got a long ways to go. Keep reading about recent history. Next you'll get depressed...
I'm actually quite happy nowadays. Every day is a day full of purpose. I'm not reactive, I'm proactive. I see the patterns and I know what's coming. I know what needs to be done.
I agree with Lessig on one point and one point alone. Code is law.
Not saying we shouldn't try the traditional approach, though. Here's some good news:
- http://www.reddit.com/r/restorethefourth/comments/1htaqf/the...
I'm sorry to hear you are dealing with depression.
>> I'm actually quite happy nowadays. Every day is a day full of purpose. I'm not reactive, I'm proactive.
Oh, well that's good.
Now that would be frustrating.
There's an important step you forgot to include: Getting the new laws enforced. When most of the people in charge of the enforcement are used to (and may well have liked) the old laws, that will not be simple.
A bit off-topic but related to law enforcement: http://www.salon.com/2013/07/07/“why_did_you_shoot_me_i_was_...
Given that, what good would a new law do? They already have everything in place to subvert any law they want, and their chief tool is mere will.
What might change things is public outrage and muscular congressional hearings, a la Watergate. I can't see that ever happening again.
Relax and join the movement... it's going to be a long ride.
DON'T relax. These feelings of frustration are absolutely NORMAL and they must be channeled into action, not relaxation.
DON'T panic! And don't forget your towel.
Or maybe we need to democratize the analogue of a submarine.
You will initially get depressed as you see the injustice around you.
You can deny what you see and go back to browsing Facebook.
Or, you can embrace the movement. I've been traveling the rabbit hole and I assure you that the thing is manageable if you put your time into it.
Here are some guidelines:
- You already have local communities (hacker/creative spaces) that have members who are on top of the news and working to escape the system. Find them.
- Find the commonality between libertarianism, anarcho-capitalism and anarcho-socialism. None of these ideologies are sufficient, but the conversations and debates are converging.
- Learn history and social/economic sciences. The history of debt money, the collapse of rome, today's corporate power structures, etc.
- Understand how the dollar works and how it's controlled and enforced. Support alternative currencies.
- Support open hardware. The EFF is your friend. Learn more about encryption and understand the vulnerabilities online and offline.
I could go on, share links, etc.
Please do.
- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSSKpL87_Rs
- http://www.boilingfrogspost.com/2013/06/19/podcast-show-112-...
- http://m.democracynow.org/web_exclusives/1781
- http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/06/23/1218189/-HBGary-Pal...
Books illuminate how power works
- http://www.amazon.com/The-Master-Switch-Information-Empires/...
- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt:_The_First_5000_Years
- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_People's_History_of_the_Unite... (I haven't read it yet, I've heard good and bad things about the book)
- http://daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf (I've only skimmed a few sections, but I suspect this is good to understand anarcho-capitalism)
To combat low level surveillance, we need open hardware.
- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_open-source_hardware_pr...
- http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=2686
Our own mesh network for community penetration. Mesh networks sort of died off a decade ago, but there is a resurgence.
- http://karmanebula.com/chicagomeshnet/
- https://www.wepay.com/donations/oakland-community-mesh-netwo...
Bitcoin is still growing, and more people are understanding the mechanism behind it. Many altcoins are just Bitcoin ripoffs, but we'll see interesting developments going forward.
- There are many technologies and protocols being built for distributed exchanges, etc. Discussions under bitcointalk.org etc.
Other links
- http://liberationtechnology.stanford.edu/
- https://mailman.stanford.edu/pipermail/liberationtech/2013-J...
- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism
- http://www.democracynow.org/
Those have just been on my mind recently. Reddit is actually a good source of reading material once you have an account, unfollow stupid subreddits and follow the right ones like politics, worldnews, restorethefourth, libertarian, anarcho_* etc.
There is no commonality. At it's core, anarchism wishes to abolish capitalism, and libertarians/ancaps wish to keep it. It's a fundamental disagreement that starts the conversation off. There's no reconciliation here.
Personally, I think if we could accomplish a RADICAL reduction in the size, scope and power of the State, that that would be a great first step, and we could then start figuring out what to do about economic systems and the property debate. But that's just me...
If you radically reduce the state without protecting the poor, you end up doing more harm to the poor. That's why anarchists are, for example, anti-austerity, even though it could be construed as "making the state smaller." Anarchists are for _the liberation of the working class_, (and all people...) and happen to believe that the state is one of the largest obstacles in achieving that goal. But removing the state without protections is just going to do far more harm than good.
You can also see this in their histories: anarchism comes from the First International, and is primarily about a means dispute with Marxists. ancap/voluntaryism comes from Rothbard, (who incidentally said that ancaps aren't anarchists...) who is... just a bit different than Marx. To understate it.
Ancaps and anarchists have almost nothing in common.
Anarcho-socialists (what steveklabnik calls "anarchists") have a reactionary attitude towards "capitalism" and see capitalism as the source of government tyranny. You'll see them claiming the word "anarchism" for themselves, and rejecting any form of capitalism.
Yet you'll find that in denying the freedom of voluntary trade, this particular group fail to propose an alternative that doesn't just turn into another tyrannical state.
I say, find an anarchist who can understand the Bitcoin protocol, and you'll find yourself an anarcho-capitalist.
The problem with anarcho-capitalism is that they believe the free market will solve everything, and they don't believe in environmental limitations, and they have no proposed mechanism of protecting the liberties of the poor. (the poor can't buy freedom, damnit).
In practice, most people admit that there should be personal property (such as your home and your body), and that there should be limitations to property (there are more empty houses in san francisco than homeless people). It's just common sense. Between anarcho-socialists and anarcho-capitalists, there is a way to achieve a good balance.
Yeah, that's always been one of my issues with anarcho-socialists - in the obsessive quest to eliminate all hierarchy, it seems that they've created a system that could only be enforced through... a hierarchy. Unless you can get every human being in a group larger than about 2 to agree on something, that is. And I'm not betting any money on that happening.
In practice, most people admit that there should be personal property (such as your home and your body), and that there should be limitations to property (there are more empty houses in san francisco than homeless people). It's just common sense. Between anarcho-socialists and anarcho-capitalists, there is a way to achieve a good balance.
Part of the problem with that is this: When you start having those kinds of discussions, what you refer to as "common sense" often winds up being a form of Utilitarianism, or based on Utilitarian arguments. And while Utilitarianism isn't necessarily Bad in any inherent way, it's an ideology like any other, and taken to it's further-most logical extremes, also leads to Bad Things being supported. See: the whole swathes of novels written about the evils of medical utilitarianism[1] gone too far.
For this reason, among others, finding a common ground between (left) anarchism and anarcho-capitalism isn't necessarily as easy as it might seem.
Right, but I didn't say that. Not as a universal statement, anyway. I'm saying that there are certain, specific situations / circumstances where they do overlap.
Ancaps and anarchists have almost nothing in common.
Agreed, but the word I'm focusing on is the "almost". Where there is something in common, we could all probably accomplish more by working together a bit. But, in my experience, an-caps are often open to collaboration with anarchist-socialists / left-anarchists / whatever-term-you-prefer, but those guys usually don't want anything to do with us. I guess I'd say it's that we don't see "traditional" anarchists as our enemy, but they see us as theirs. But what can ya do? shrug
Fair enough. Frankly, I probably just should have not even replied, as my hostility stems from being sick of having this conversation over and over and over. See your siblings implying that anarchists are against 'free trade', or that they don't understand bitcoin...
The rhetoric when you understand both sides of this is immensely tiring.
I never tire of correcting someone, even correcting myself or allowing others to correct me. So go ahead and convince me of something.
1. No anarchist wants to stop you from trading things with anyone. Capitalism != trade. The issue is ownership of the means of production, not movables.
2. I personally understand Bitcoin quite well, which is one of the reasons I don't like it. however, I've seen quite a few of my fellow anarchists support it thoroughly, to the point of saying "If you don't support Bitcoin, you're not an anarchist." I _will_ say that I'm warming up to it slightly as a certain tactic for certain situations.
As I'm already irritated, you'll have to forgive me if I don't say more than that. Maybe another time.
The thing is, Edward Snowden was the 1st one to show us he's ready to die for this cause.
I'm sure the number of people willing to go further will only increase. And that will ultimately lead to actions.
EDIT: The movement will "only" have to make sure not be sabotaged and killed off by the surveillance state, along the way.