If that's so, how do you account for the relation between Sanskrit, Latin and Greek (and Russian, and English...)?
Or do you deny the relation altogether? Do you have a competing theory that you could point me to?
If that's so, how do you account for the relation between Sanskrit, Latin and Greek (and Russian, and English...)?
Or do you deny the relation altogether? Do you have a competing theory that you could point me to?
Also, the notion that the PIE reconstructions describe a "language" in the sense that we usually understand it (a vernacular tongue of a group of people in a single time and place) is a false one: even though the reconstructions with very high likelihood represent individual IE language features in an old form thereof, it would be a folly to try to slap them together and say "this is a language that someone spoke", for the same reason you can't reconstruct individual genes from the tree of mammals, slap them together and say "this was the first mammal". It doesn't work like that. What you get is a constrained probability function over possible languages, not a single solution with 100% probability.