>
Research shows that you're not typical - most people find it massively demotivatingWhat is "it", exactly? Any public criticism? Public belittling (which is severely different from a proper dressing down)? Swearing? There's a lot mixed in here.
And does research conclusively establish a significantly different reaction to otherwise identical acts in public vs private?
> I'd rather go with programmers behave broadly as other people do.
Even if programmers behave broadly as other people do, that doesn't mean they'd have the same reaction to the same behavior in two very different scenarios.
Our dressing-downs[1] are as likely to come from our peers as our management. And even when they come from managers, we have a much different relationship with them. We are in positions of relative power and economic security, as well as positions of trust. A manager is more peer or patron than overlord, and we are more agent than minion. This is a very different dynamic than most jobs.
I question the relevance of any research on this that doesn't specifically target highly-skilled fields with economically-secure workers.
[1] Dressings down? Can you make bandages out of soft feathers?