Rollbar. We used to use Airbrake but Rollbar has been much better for us. It is still pretty new but they are constantly adding features.
I've been using Sentry [1] lately and it has been excellent. Only issue has been that using SSL from Java was quite troublesome as their certificate is not supported by the JVM by default [2].
[1] http://getsentry.com [2] https://github.com/getsentry/sentry/issues/903
Edit: Rollbar looks interesting. Too bad they don't have an API for Java.