The dirty little secret of PaaS is that there is not, and will never be a single PaaS that fits everyone's needs. With docker we offer a foundation for many PaaSes to engage in a healthy competition while preserving interoperability.
So Shopify will always be free to mix and match Flynn's lego bricks with the bricks of other offerings - because they are all Docker-compatible. The authors of Flynn get that, which is why I believe their product will be good and I will be personally sponsoring it :)
I'm not complaining that an alternative to Cloud Foundry is going to exist, but I'm still a bit surprised.
People who value a little extra effort at startup as being a cost that is more than $200/month over the life of their use of dotCloud.
There's a lot of cases where that could be true, especially if the extra effort and moving to a different platform is deferred, rather than permanent. There are many times where doing something now (that isn't necessary for immediate goals, but is useful for long-term savings) has greater opportunity costs than doing it later. (Lots of times when the reverse is true, as well.)
If I compared to DigitalOcean instead, then DotCloud would look even worse -- about 10x more expensive.
You see where I'm trying to go with that?
GitHub did not create Git, nor is their code open source.
Much respect for DotCloud's success thusfar btw.
This supposed competitive advantage that they would have would mean nothing if they still had to work on top of other IaaS-providers. They would be undercut by the IaaS themselves. By changing the game, they get another angle to work from.