At the end of the day aren't they likely liable?
I played this game with Dreamhost and SunTrust back with their whole billing debacle in Jan 2008. Dreamhost didn't respond to my support requests to reimburse "non-sufficient funds fees", The bank manager at SunTrust said that regardless of the reason funds weren't available in my account when the other transactions posted, so the NSF fees that I was incurring were legitimate.
In the end I think I paid a little over $300 for their mistake.