It's the same argument as always, just with a spin that you may not have thought of before.
It's the same argument as always, just with a spin that you may not have thought of before.
First, there was no rule of law, and the citizen had no protection but to supplicate to the most powerful.
Then, there was the rule of law, but the laws were written by someone else.
Then, there came democracy, and citizens had some sort of indirect input to ruling themselves.
Afterward, commercial interests found that they could exercise power over others using the framework of markets, and monopolys and other abuses had to be curtailed.
Information was not so easily manipulated and aggregated when our country was founded, but the importance of what happens to information and who has control over it has increased as our ability to leverage information processing has increased. As a result, we are becoming aware of new, hitherto unrecognized rights. We're going to have to fight for them. I'm not sure if we need to do this politically, commercially, or with a combination of the two.
At first, when developers sent us information and it was on our computers, Stallman said that we should be able to use this information in any way we chose, since it was our freedom to use our property that was at stake. I agree with this.
Now, however, when we send information to the developers, it seems that Stallman has switched sides, and doesn't believe that that recipient or holder of the information should be free to do as they will with it. In light of this, maybe it was never freedom to use information we had that was important to Stallman, but something else that coincided.
Also, in Stallman's world, if you don't want to share your source, you're free to keep it to yourself. Likewise, he urges users to keep their information to themselves.
Given that you have to give your SSN for all kinds of miscellaneous stuff where you don't particularly trust the recipient, these days (credit apps, etc), I don't think anyone has the illusion that their SSN is private, do they? Still?
Privacy is effectively dead, and the only substitute we have is secrecy, which can be destroyed by any party to the secret. This is the world we live in, now, and I can't see any way to reverse course, no matter what the law says.
Yes, but remember, I'm talking about the situation in Stallman's world. No one would use non-open software, and no one would send their personal information.
As far as privacy being dead, "dead" is a misleading term here. Privacy is a concept, and as such has no vital signs. It can be alive again as easily as a comic book character. The transition from the time before universal suffrage is just as big as the change from the current situation to privacy as a right.
If you ask ordinary people about these topics, you'll find that many, if not most people out there have some sort of expectation about privacy. I think that these are rights waiting to be discovered. Just as my downloading a GPL'ed app or marking the checkbox under the Terms of Service means I agree to a specific contract, I think that there should be certain implicit contract going the other direction. Just as no one should be able to, say, sell kitchen utensils that blow up and kill people.
The SSN as a secret is in trouble. However, there are more robust protocols than the secret number.
In that case, both my blathering and Stallman's would be irrelevant, on this subject.
I think that universal suffrage is not in the same category as privacy, because nothing about technological advance really dictated it. Privacy and copyright are more like slavery (not making a moral statement here!), in that after certain technological advances, it's just not possible to sustain them and continue competing economically. That's what I mean when I say that privacy is dead: without some unforeseen technological problem (or solution, if you're so inclined) that makes it possible to control other people's computers with your software against their will, it's only a matter of time until societal mores catch up and recognize the de facto situation.
Actually, what you're talking about is Digital Rights Management. IF DRM worked, it could be used in the other direction, and your private information could be distributed in the form of software agents. Big if here, granted. However, I suspect that something like Vernor Vinge's "Trusted Computing Environment" will eventually exist. It's too useful not to.
There is another mechanism that already can "control other people's computers with your software against their will" using legal means. Namely the GPL.
Something like the GPL combined with simple protocols can protect private information, say, like a number. Using one-time proxy-numbers, I can already shop with my credit card, but without revealing my account number. Craigslist also has a similar mechanism to protect emails. If this were built into email clients, then it would be easy for users to register, and always know exactly who sold their email address to spammers.
Better yet, why not build registration protocols into browsers in the same way RSS reading and SSL session key negotiation is?
This sort of thing will not completely prevent the aggregation and inference of private data. But combine these mechanisms with legal protections of privacy, and it will make it very hard for corporations to use the data they aggregate illegally.
only a matter of time until societal mores catch up and recognize the de facto situation
There was a time when the US was very cavalier about copyright, and we just up and published our own editions of books without paying royalties. Societal mores were fine with this. (Dickens had to go on tour and do readings of _A Christmas Carol_ to make money from it in the US!) Somehow, the situation shifted the other direction in this case.
I agree that it's a big 'if', because I don't think that DRM will actually ever work reasonably well, and I don't think usefulness is a huge boost -- there are too many confounding factors, even if the encryption itself isn't cracked.
I'm not sure what to quote of the middle of your post. :) First off, "legal" is pretty fluid; I can find a jurisdiction that allows me to do whatever I want with personal information. Second, once someone has a copy of personal information in an unencrypted format, the source becomes very difficult to identify (unless everyone gets a customized copy, as you point out for email; I used a scheme like this to track who was selling my email to spammers from 1998 for a few years, but it didn't do me any good to find out, and it was a bit of trouble to keep up with).
But essentially, privacy and copyright are the same fight, and if you can come up with an effective enforcement tool for either one, the other one is solved as well.
Somehow, the situation shifted the other direction in this case.
I'm not suggesting that there's any social inevitability, here, except as a result of a technological one.
The GPL seems to work regardless. It works because it is respected by and large by the programmer community, and because most of the relevant places respect the relevant laws.
Second, once someone has a copy of personal information in an unencrypted format, the source becomes very difficult to identify (unless everyone gets a customized copy, as you point out for email;
A "Trusted Computing Environment" would ensure that only the trusted environment would ever get a copy.
I used a scheme like this to track who was selling my email to spammers from 1998 for a few years, but it didn't do me any good to find out, and it was a bit of trouble to keep up with).
If it was implemented as a protocol and integrated in the browser, the user would only have to see "Received at address send to X" and the rest could happen automatically.
I'm not suggesting that there's any social inevitability, here, except as a result of a technological one.
But printing kept on getting more efficient throughout the Industrial Revolution. The cost of transcription was a relative non-issue. The technology trended in a direction that would indicate more copying. Yet it came to pass that there was less copying of books and that it wasn't as acceptable. Why?
Democracy doesn't mean anything because it is two wolves and one sheep deciding what to eat for dinners. However, guns in the hand of the people matters. When people have guns, they have the ability to protect themsleves from a brewing mob. It creates for a more... polite society.
I think those three are enough to protect the citizen's rights over their private information, without the guns. However, I think that these are lacking in sufficient measure in our society.
If people are asked to hand over their guns, than it is the same as having no defense. It is the same as giving up liberty. It is the same as letting yourself and everyone else be massacared.(The Nazis will have an extremely difficult time of exterminating the Jews if all Jews are well armed)
Words are not substitue for armed men who cannot easily be coreced into giving up his liberty.
That is why the founding father put in the 2nd Amendment because they forseen the possiblity that the government of this country may become tyrannical. Without arms, there are no way to resist the government when it decided to turn on the population.
The guns are an implementation detail. The tools you need are generally context-specific. Malone: "You wanna know how you do it? Here's how, they pull a knife, you pull a gun." What if they're destroying your culture, your economic substrate? Bringing a gun to this party is like bringing a knife to go after Malone. (The Untouchables.)
Knowledge, intelligence, and organization are fundamental. These are the fundamental means of defense, which the populace has given up.
The Nazis accomplished an impressive feat of data processing to collate the identity information of almost all of the Jews in the territories they controlled. If the Nazis lacked that, far more lives would have been saved than arming the Jewish minorities. A gunfight is one of the outcomes they would have wanted. It would have been a propaganda coup for them! And if the Jews had been an unorganized mob, so much the better for them.
Personally I don't worry about that. What I worry about is the safety of my data. When the day comes when I can't use a desktop client to download email from GMail, or when I won't be able to open a .doc file without M. Office, then I'll be worried.
> If it's not, everyone is at the mercy of one company.
I don't know about that. I've heard it from Stallman's talks but it's too dramatic for my taste. What people should be worrying about is open specs to protocols and file formats.
The best example of a software monopoly is Windows, and if Windows was the only operating system available, then we'd surely be at the mercy of one company.
But that's not the case and while some people can point to the GPL as the catalyst, that's not necessarily the case. It might be the technology's fast pace or the academia which has always favored collaboration, not to mention that the open source model of development is in many ways just better.
I don't think software is the domain in which monopolies can be established indefinitely.
But then it will be too late.