12 Years of GPL Compliance: A Historical Perspective
ebb.org
ebb.org
This is an interesting piece about how Tim O'Reilly tried, and succeeded, to de-politicize free software, and make it "business friendly": http://www.thebaffler.com/past/the_meme_hustler
The OSI's own account gives O'Reilly a far smaller role than the Baffler piece:
* http://opensource.org/history
* http://opensource.org/faq#free-software
* http://web.archive.org/web/19981206185148/http://www.opensou...
It just pretends that it's opinions and practices aren't political, despite their enormous and very deliberate impact on the way society functions and public policy is made.
The industry's politics are mostly disguised by claiming it's the objective truth, or "that's just the way things work". You can see examples of it here on HN in pretty much every thread that isn't 100% technical.
And even then, like Mitch Kapor said "Architecture is policy". The fact that we don't feel comfortable acknowledging it in a society that has become anti-political doesn't mean it isn't about politics.
Hell, attempts to de-politicize such things are in themselves expressions of political ideology.
Edit: A talk I did about Bandluxe's PR39 at BlackHat Europe 2012 is here for those interested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ZAjtxmxTkg
My answer to most of the naysaying here would be simply to say that GPL is the Constitution of a Free Software community who chose to refuse any proprietarization of their work. If you believe in the principles of a Constitution, then it's worth upholding that Constitution.
And, I don't do this full-time. GPL enforcement has never been my full-time work, but has been the minority plurality of my work since 1999. And I get paid less than every software developer I know, BTW, and my salaries since 2001 are all publicly known. :)
--edit-- thanks to both replies below. Wasn't meant as a criticism, I was just expecting an article rather than slides.
I guess there will be a Beamer version of the talk as well.
If the end result of GPL is 1) a few companies completely refuse to distribute GPLed software (Apple, for example) and 2) the rest of the companies use GPLed code without following the rules but with no consequence 3) huge amounts of money and effort are thrown against these forces, with only symbolic levels of success in changing company behavior
... why are we even bothering?
That Don Quixote slide seems especially appropriate.
Software developers has a similar situation as photographers has. Almost all companies ignore copyright on images when they publish a website, but they do respect the copyright after being informed about infringement.
So it only takes a singular individual from the public to inform the company. It doesn't need to be the author of the work to get the license enforced in the common case.
Also, I was under the impression that very little money and effort was put into attempting to enforce the GPL through lawsuits (and these slides don't seem to suggest otherwise, naming just a few people and suites over the years). Is it more common than I think?
But to answer your question: this whole thing makes me want to reconsider licensing my software as GPL. Just do MIT and not have to think about it.
If you do want to use GPL then just like belorn said, the 'or later' clause keeps GPL compability against later versions and I believe a majority of GPL projects use that. Linux is of course a notable exception.