I guess what makes me so skeptical about this is the magnitude of change in expectations that relatively minor news can bring. I would say that a rational person should not, for example, value Google or Facebook 20% less or more more because of a single quarter's performance. I feel like one of three things must be the case:
- A slight miss or hit of earnings expectations in a quarter
really can make a rational person change their valuation
of a company by 20%.
- The market is irrational.
- The spot price doesn't accurately represent the market.
It's harder for me to believe the first two than the last one.