Absolutely. And to find a way out of this, you first need to completely take the money out of politics - radically, entirely.
I see the corruption of Washington (and then: democracy) via money as the core problem, in the US.
Absolutely. And to find a way out of this, you first need to completely take the money out of politics - radically, entirely.
I see the corruption of Washington (and then: democracy) via money as the core problem, in the US.
You can get votes by promising free chickens in every pot. You can get votes by bringing a big defense contract into an area. Politicians get elected by votes, and the political system runs on votes.
Yes, money is used to fight the battle. But focusing on the money is idiotic. Money is a completely secondary factor. It's main modern use (I speak of direct contributions, not the sweetheart deals to relatives that really is at the heart of corruption) is to attack the opponent's base and prevent them from turning out to vote.
Also, political power is much more important than money. Being able to launch a Predator strike trumps any amount of campaign contributions.
This focus on money has to stop. It's like saying businesses are all about making money. It's not that it's a false statement -- it's that it misses the point entirely of what's going on. Business provide value by giving folks stuff they want. Money is a secondary way to keep score. Political power is accumulated by votes. If you can gain a thousand votes by simply making a speech, much better than throwing money at folks. It's an easy win. Focusing on money ignores the entirety of what's really going on.
You want a really corrupt system, start overengineering the money side.
http://www.ted.com/talks/lawrence_lessig_we_the_people_and_t...
But, as an example, I'd just like to mention the obscene amounts of money being wasted during presidential elections. Why should candidates be allowed to be able to get more votes because they spend more money because they literally got paid/owned by some private interests/ultra-rich people? It's just plain stupidity. How can we allow that?
We're technically not exactly there yet, b/c not every household has an Internet connection yet, but why shouldn't the goal be this:
Set up just 1 website where all political parties can express their positions. And let that be the only allowed form of communication with the voter.
It's a sane pull versus an insane push approach.
And it would take a lot of money out of politics, which can then be spent for intelligent things like research, for example.
This is a simplistic example, but that's basically what the famous Citizens United case was about - did a wealthy third party have the right to publish something designed to influence an election (in that case, by saying negative things about Hilary Clinton)? The first amendment says pretty clearly that Congress cannot make any law that limits the freedom of the press, and so people who want to use their money to publish election messages have to be allowed to do it.
As a European I agree that it's far from ideal, but that's something you have to accept if you want the freedoms of the first amendment as it is written.
Why shouldn't money have meaning in the political realm? If you take away the ability of wealth to actually influence the world, then all you can do when you're rich is buy increasingly banal toys.
America is, in theory, a representative democracy and not some kind of plutocracy or aristocracy. That is your answer.
America was once a republic, precisely to avoid the madness we are talking about in this thread. One by one the protections against mob rule have been dismantled.
> America was once a republic
The two are not incompatible. And it pretty unquestionably still is a republic and, in form at least, is also a representative democracy.
I know of no reasonable definition of "republic" under which either of these statements is defensible. "Republic" doesn't mean a system of government that produces exclusively outcomes that meet with Daniel_Newby's approval.
You seem, again, to be conflating what you like with what a Republic is.
It doesn't mean that one person cannot be more influential than the other due to charisma, logical reasoning, or by using money to simply have their message heard by more people.
For instance, no matter how rich you are and how many TV spots you buy out, you're unlikely to convince the population to do something that they inherently dislike. In a true plutocracy, the rich don't need to convince anyone of their feelings, their power is written into the system.
OK, so candidates can only use one site. Then "Friends of Candidate" will set up a site, or some random blogger with a million followers will set up a website. There is no stopping the message, or the money. The voting system needs to change, among other things. the government should also do less, so there is less power to be had at the top.
I am certainly not against any part of the constitution!
> OK, so candidates can only use one site. Then "Friends of Candidate" will set up a site, or some random blogger with a million followers will set up a website.
Of course that is and should be possible, because it is free speech!
The thing is: it should be made illegal to advertise such a blog with money. Of course there will still the possibility of abuse, but that is the case with any other law.
Doing what I propose would make a huge difference in the money-based corruption of the entire system.
Once you get voted in, all of a sudden you've got control over a – for all intents and purposes – unlimited money tap.
This encourages the sort of people who think "skimming a little bit off the top" of the government provided money flow (aka "stealing from the taxpayer") is OK, to enter the political arena for self-serving reasons.
I don't know how much this is a real problem – there's a good argument that "enlightened self interest" is perhaps the best motivator for politicians, but I know where I live (Sydney, Australia) our local state government is currently involved in many many scandals where politicians have been caught using their positions to create great wealth for themselves and their family/friends under extremely suspicious circumstances (mysterious real estate deals in areas which subsequently get significant changes in legal status, planning permission given to industries with no public consultation followed by executive level jobs or board positions when responsible politicians leave office).
In an "ideal world", people seeking political power for personal self-interest would be excluded in favour of people with purely altruistic intentions. Unfortunately that's about as practical as appointing me as Emperor of the Universe.
There was HBO special on vote machine maker (the corp name get changed often).
Since votes are rigged, it's not democracy. The congress popularity is < 10%, now you know how they get reelected.