In Defense Of Leakers: Snowden and Manning
newyorker.com
newyorker.com
Coming out in support of whistle-blowers may seem non-controversial on HN and similar sites, but we do have a long way to go before swaying public opinion. We can help a little by discussing it with friends and family, and by letting our politicians know we're not OK with it.
I'm not sure what else to do or whether it's even helping. I wonder what kind of response we will get to the White House petition to pardon Snowden, but I expect it to be one-sided nonsense.
At least in the case of Snowden, public opinion is against him and he is labelled as a "traitor" because people think it is perfectly fine for the government to spy on them, because unless they are doing something wrong, they have nothing to hide and nothing to fear. This dangerous argument is the reason that most people do not seem to care enough on why your government spying on you is a very bad thing and the ramifications of it, even if you are not doing something wrong. Throw in the "extreme" threat of terrorism on top of this, and most people are totally OK with the NSA programs: "I have nothing to hide and this helps prevent terrorism and therefore Snowden is a traitor for putting Americans at risk."
I think it is more that the majority of people do not believe that the government is spying on them. Most people do not understand that it does not take a team of government agents to spy on a person. The issue is not merely that people think they have nothing to hide, but that they do not even understand that they are being watched.
It could also be that a small majority do agree with you, but simply don't care. I'm sure you can think of some policies of the federal government you don't like, but you just don't spend any time trying to fight, other than the occasional Internet comment (you have gone beyond the occasional Internet comment on this issue, right?)
When the public doesn't agree with you, or just doesn't care that much about your issue, it doesn't mean they are lazy uninformed idiots. That is a sophomoric way of looking at the world, it's not true, and it's not useful to think that way.
Disagrees based on what? Labeling someone as traitor doesn't constitute a rational counter-argument to concerns regarding privacy and government checks and balances in this case. Such argument should start with something like "I feel these programs are necessary because" and end with something that doesn't involve ultra-generic buzzwords.
It is possible but almost certainly not the case. Most people do not know enough about computers to understand what the NSA programs even entail. It is pretty hard for the general public to make informed decisions about computer or Internet policies, laws, or government involvement.
Would you like to point out where I made such an idiotic claim? I didn't mean or intent to imply that the only reason people don't agree with me is because they don't know. My point was simply that a lot of people are ignorant. What's not useful is this sort of straw-man pedantry.
As for those who agree but don't care: it's hard to blame them. I signed petitions, I sent letters to my elected representatives. I tried to attend a protest, but it was so pathetic that I left. I try, but there's a sense of futility to it all.
I'm very open to suggestions on how we can have a greater impact.
Were they stuffed with cash? Nothing talks like campaign donations.
All the vote promises in the world don't mean squat if they can't print enough flyers so that Joe Blow will recognize their name when they step into the booth.
Of course, no politician is going to care about donations on the level that your average middle-class American can afford to give. Maybe crowd-fund a large sum for donation whose receipt is contingent upon an agreement to vote a certain way on certain issues, with highly public and embarrassing repercussions if they do not?
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/06/18/19024443-analysis....
That's fairly straightforward and it's getting tiresome hearing the term "whistle-blower", which is intended more for dog-food factory workers reporting the use of rotten horse meat, rather than people releasing gigantic, undifferentiated masses of state secrets.
Second, releasing data securely is so trivial that both of these guys must have had a specific reason for not doing so. I mean, a humanitarian impulse would have led them to use the dark net and other channels, but neither of these guys did so.
In Manning's case it could have been a simple matter of a personality disorder, which he clearly had:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/may/28/bradley-manning....
...in Snowden's case, being a sane, smart guy, he either thought he could get away with high crimes through a clever escape, or he was an agent for China, Russia, or even the NSA itself. There's no serious defense for either. And as has been said before, nothing that has been released is the least surprising to anyone paying attention.
If there's nothing, then you can dismiss them as not a serious person. If they have an answer you have a beginning point for a conversation that may not be a waste of time for both of you.
The US needed no help to embarrass itself. It chose the course it has taken with Guantanamo and Manning and Binney and Drake, chose to lie repeatedly to Americans about what it's been up to, chose to subvert the FISA's original purpose. It's up to Congress to end the embarrasment.
So I wonder if they reduce program size if all the sudden there will be terrorist attack. Wouldn't that be interesting.
Also, if we spend 10 billion on the NSA and what does our terrorist enemies spend?
[1] http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/03/the-horr...