I agree with this guy. Mitch's talk was well put together and thoughtful. I think building a diverse team (assuming everybody is highly capable of course) wins most of the time.
We know diversity over the long-term is safer. Perhaps in startups, where the timespan is short, specialization and myopic vision win out?
Where do you see examples of diverse startups being successful? From what I see most are made up of young male geeks who could be brothers.
If your universe of startups is just YC funded companies, then sure, but even there, I think you're excluding some.