Hacker News Reader

Comment by tptacek | Hacker News Reader

It's not enough for you that we agree that the program is bad. We have to agree for all the right reasons. This is a perfect illustration of why HN is a terrible place to discuss politics.

Here's why: we have a situation where, for once, we've landed on the same conclusion. We got there for different reasons. Instead of looking at that as a great opportunity to learn something new from our differing perspectives, it's something that somehow manages to piss you off. If political discussion doesn't work here, it's certainly not going to work anywhere else.

I'm not getting my wish that discussions like these simply be banned from the site, but maybe we could take a baby step towards civility by not calling people names.

View on HN

First, I am in no way pissed off.

Second, I actually really enjoy talking about these things with you on HN.

Third, we both get emotional about things we discuss - I recall a thread between us ~2 plus years ago where we were in heated discussion!

And C) - these items are political - but entirely germane to HN as the whole thing is enabled by tech and techies "just following orders" and tech companies "just making more sales".

We are on a very slippery slope; nobody wants to live in danger, but everyone is in danger of government abuse with these programs.

Hey, just in the interest of thwarting a false equivalence: I haven't called you names. You have called me names, on this very thread. I'm not super offended and would still buy you a beer in person, but let's all be clear that we're not supposed to be doing that on HN.

You were never called any names. He said you were an apologist. In reading your postings, your comments do strike me as having an overtone of apology for the surveillance state.

In political matters - the power of government vs. the rights of the individual - most people will fall into one of the two groups as a basic mode of operation for their perceptions and personal philosophy. When governments become tyrannical, as the US government is now proving itself to be, the contrast between the two modes becomes starkly delineated.

Authority vs. Liberty is an ancient human argument that is obviously still being played out. Those of us with an unbreakable attachment to Liberty will see any arguments in favor of the current regime as apologia.

"You were never called any names. He said you were an apologist."

Well there you go.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com