This article is so biased and reeks of agenda. There are no other more sympathetic people to do news stories for? My BS radar just off the charts. If you can look past the fair amount of cash in the car and the drug paraphernalia then there is a need for outrage. However, I can't.
While I might see a reason for seizure laws I could easily see them being abused. That said, the example given in the article isn't going to win over any opponents.
It doesn't matter one tiny little bit if you think the people in question are drug runners, or even if they actually are, in fact, drug runners. All that matters is that the government took their property as a de facto punishment for having committed a crime (running drugs) without ever actually proving that they committed a crime.
So yeah, there was definitely an agenda here, but it seems to have been to demonstrate a genuinely scary trend in law enforcement and government overreach, which is exactly what it should be.
Of course, pretty much everyone has 'drug paraphernalia' lying around somewhere. My coffee grinder, my wife's kitchen scales, our snack-sized sandwich bags, the spoons in our cutlery drawer...
However, police are able to arrest for a crime at any point of the process. That said, other than ones that aren't reversible (like murder), they usually let you commit the crime and then arrest you. This makes it easier to prosecute you.
I don't necessarily have a problem with asset forfeiture just that it needs to be required to be associated with a conviction, there should be a cap on what the police get (to avoid overzealous use), and there should be a quick and logical appeal process to prevent innocents having property taken via 'splash damage'.
Nothing wrong with that agenda.
One could certainly give the benefit of the doubt to the police in any particular case where there's a large amount of cash drug paraphenelia involved. However, when this happens to a large number of people (who are never charged but their assets are seized) it's pretty clear what's going on.
In any case, the class action lawsuit was settled in the plaintiffs' favor so clearly, the police department must have recognized that they would lose (especially when the state declined to defend them).
Here you go. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_P._Scott
See also: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/the-governments-war-on...
and: http://www.volokh.com/2010/04/06/institute-for-justice-repor...