Bitcoin is now a declared currency in Texas.
techcrunch.com
techcrunch.com
Citation needed.
From the opinion: "The question currently before the Court is whether the BTCST investments in this case are securities as defined by Federal Securities Laws."
This case was about whether a dude who was accepting deposits of Bitcoins and paying interest on them was in the securities business. Of course he was.
> The ruling represents yet another attempt to regulate Bitcoin transactions
Frickin' awesome. Finally they're going to get acceptance from the mainstream, and my investments will be worth something...
> Bitcoin was born on the idea that nobody could regulate it.
Really? I always thought it was born on the idea of making its creator rich. Either way, its value comes from the inability for players to unilaterally (and meaningfully) increase the money supply.
> The only real value of a Bitcoin comes from its users
Kinda like every other currency, then?
The US dollar has even more demand. All Americans are required by law to purchase it and own it for the purpose of paying their taxes. If they do not, the most powerful police and military will lock them in prison. This is the base upon which the rest of the system is built.
Bitcoin, to its good fortune, is also backed by independent demand: crime. Because of crime, and its adeptness at enforcing agreements, BitCoin has a strong tangible base upon which it can grow its ecosystem. The biggest threat to BitCoin is not a sudden loss of interest by the masses, but a competing currency that better serves crime and takes BitCoin's market share.
Every Bitcoin transaction is a matter of public record. There's no anonymity - everything you do with Bitcoin leaves a paper trail. Criminals using Bitcoin expose themselves to a much greater risk of detection than they'd face by using a briefcase full of dollars. There are ways to mitigate the traceability of Bitcoin transactions, but these typically involve trusting middlemen, and so come with their own set of risks.
The value of Bitcoin originates in the inability of the government to manipulate the money supply, but I suspect that criminals are probably less impacted by inflation than the typical non-criminal is.
It's honest businesspeople and not criminals who stand to benefit from Bitcoin.
Cash is a terrible currency for big time crime. It is very difficult to store, being susceptible to mites and fungus. It is very difficult to exchange large quantities, think pallets instead of briefcases for millions/billions of dollars (which is the primary reason they don't make a $1000 bill). It is nearly impossible to exchange any meaningful amount cross-border. It is difficult to count and keep track of. It is easier to counterfeit and get bad cash. Cash has serial numbers, fingerprints, and DNA all over them (I'm surprised we don't hear more about cash forensics, or bugged cash with tracking chips in them).
Cash will still be used for the last mile, for the street-level "retail" transactions. But when those get gathered up and need to be sent back to headquarters, or between organizations, or to other nations, the backhaul, by necessity, needs to run on something more sophisticated. Today, that seems to be Bitcoin, even though I agree with you that it is far from perfect. Its first-mover advantage is allowing it to build a robust ecosystem of services that is making it that much harder for an incumbent to take its place. But when that super currency does come, and crime shifts to using it, I predict a relatively straight decline in BitCoin value.
Federal judges have acknowledged that Bitcoin has the underpinnings that constitutes it as a currency. This is HUGELY exciting.
Disclosure: I work in financial regulatory reporting and am bullish on bitcoin.
Courts deal with the issues in the cases before them. The relevant issue in this case was whether an investment sold for bitcoin involved a transaction of "money" for purposes of the Exchange Act of 1934, making it subject to various securities-related rules.
The status of other altcoins (or even bitcoin's status as "currency" in any sense other than the specific context of the Exchange Act) was not an issue before the court.
The IRS wanted to be paid for the value of the piece, but the people who inherited it were trying to argue that since they're not allowed to sell it it has no value. And I don't think they could just afford out of pocket whatever the IRS was claiming was owed.
The piece couldn't be sold because it features a stuffed bald eagle (of which sale and even ownership of is prohibited by the 1940 Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act and the 1918 Migratory Bird Treaty Act).
I did dig up these:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/22/arts/design/a-catch-22-of-...
http://www.forbes.com/sites/janetnovack/2012/07/22/the-irs-a...
http://dontmesswithtaxes.typepad.com/dont_mess_with_taxes/20...
The outcome was that they donated to the MoMa, but weren't allowed to claim a tax deduction for the donation. So yeah... kind of screwed.