Alas, I expect it won't happen, but thanks for the information.
A question. You say:
> ... more specific techniques such as Joux's latest
> function field sieve tend to be harder to transfer
> from one setting to the other.
Do you have any sense that perhaps, as we come to understand it in more detail, we may yet come to find that it becomes more widely applicable? Obviously you feel at the moment that it's too specific, but is that perhaps because we don't understand it properly yet? Or do you feel it's genuinely limited in that regard? I'm just thinking about how Wiles' insights and proofs about the (speaking loosely) limited form of the equivalence of specific Elliptic Curves and Modular Forms opened the field for the full proof of the T-S conjecture (now theorem).Just looking for a deeper insight into your intuition. Feel free to speculate wildly. If you're right you can appear prescient. If wrong, it was just speculation. 8-)
Added in edit: Supersingular Primes for Rational Points on Modular Curves (?)
Just for fun, see also: http://www.solipsys.co.uk/images/JaoAndWright_c.png
Something like Pollard rho requires no structure. It works in any group. The number field sieve is an intermediate case. It requires a norm (basically you need some elements to be bigger than others). For arbitrary finite fields, the NFS still represents the fastest known attack. The latest attack is a version of the function field sieve. The FFS uses, in an essential way, the algebraic structure of polynomials over a field. Coppersmith pioneered the use of the FFS in the 80s, when he showed that small characteristic fields (which consist primarily of polynomials) admit faster discrete logarithm solutions. The latest work goes far beyond Coppersmith's work, but tends towards increasing specialization, not generalization, since it adds the new requirement that the field contain an intermediate subfield.
Given that the direction of specialization appears, if anything, to be going in the other direction, there would have to be a substantial further breakthrough in order to apply these results more generally. My own opinion and intuition is that these results are not likely to apply to prime field discrete logs, never mind RSA and/or composite moduli.