Ask PG: Can we limit reply count/depth?
I understand that HN has always been an experiment, so why not experiment with a different way to manage the conversation? Writing a top-level post is more challenging than a follow-on reply. I suspect you'd find that top-level posts generally display more novel thought than the majority of reply posts (not all -- there are some very high quality replies -- but most).
Similarly, when a reply thread gets very deep there is a good chance that the conversation has strayed from what is interesting to the general population. At this point, it would probably be better to continue the discussion in email or some other communication medium.
I still come to HN primarily for the comments, but I find myself increasingly opening a comment link only to find a first comment followed by a page of replies to replies to replies; almost a straight line across and down my browser window. Sometimes I will scroll to see if maybe the second top-level post has a different take or covers a different question, but more often I close the page and move on...
...obviously this is just a thought. I wonder if there other things HN might try to maintain the level of discourse with its ever growing audience?