The 10,000 Hours Rule Doesn’t Exist
99u.com
99u.com
Every 100 hours I devote to something, I look back and think "God, was I ever that bad/clueless?". The more time you spend on something, the more you realize that there is more to know.
The 10,000 hour rule is just a general rule of thumb that's backed by a significant body of research. It's a correlation, so to imply it doesn't exist would require hard data that indicate otherwise. Athleticism is a straw man, and makes for a poor disproof.
Having read Outliers, I'm not sure that Gladwell was so prescriptive that he thought that 10,000 hours was the only thing that mattered, I think he was just making the case that it was a prerequisite for getting there. There are a lot of musicians who have played 10,000 hours and aren't as good as The Beatles, or a lot of people who have coded for 10,000 hours and aren't Bill Gates. Talent does matter.
The book isn't an explanation for the thesis of the 10,000 hours rule. It's an explanation for why outliers exist. In the case of sports, it appears to be a conjunction of physical size + willingness of coaches to round out the edges of their ability. With complex tasks, it appears to be myriad practice.
I read Malcolm Gladwell's book. I'm paraphrasing here, but I distinctly recall his champion example being that of musicians - future music teachers at an elite school had accumulated ~3000 hours before graduating, while the elite musicians had at or over 10000 hours total.
I think it's important not to take these things too literally. I mean, come on, it's not like Gladwell actually believes life is essentially an RPG where you grind for 10,000 hours until your skill xp is "maxed" - there's no magical moment of mastery.
You practice a lot. Take it at face value. Putting all this science into it obfuscates the process and distracts you from practicing.
A good part of the book was spent dealing with natural ability. There was an entire discussion of geniuses, and a description of where they ended up. Gladwell isn't saying that anyone is capable of anything if they put 10,000 hours of work into it.
What he said was that at the highest level of performance, within the subset of those that do have the prerequisites to perform at a world-class level in what they do, the factor that differentiates people is how much effort they put into it.
That still holds in all of this and neither this shallow regurgitation of Epstein's work nor Epstein's work itself are at odds with that. In my opinion, all Epstein's work really shows is that the prerequisites for excelling at physical activities are more selective than those for other things, which most people would probably agree with intuitively.
Fluff and blogspam.
I really wanted to read the article after the first quote, and the more I look around as to how to scroll down, the more frustrated I became.
For all developers out there, please the fact that you can implement a feature (in this case a ridiculous style of scrolling) doesn't necessarily mean you should