Ask HN: Disappointed with the current state of discourse
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6216685
The justification for this sort of heavy-handed, draconian, and dictatorial policy is in the interest of keeping the HN community "pure" and avoiding the eternal September that Reddit and Slashdot have faced.
However, there comes a point with all leadership, where laserlike focus on absolving a single problem that presents itself regardless of what circumstances exist, and the problem that can be solved without heavy-handed and draconian approaches, yet continues to grow worse. We saw this approach with USG, and I fear it is coming to Hacker News.
There needs to be discussion on how to present the best way forward for this community. We can't solve the problem of the eternal September unless we take a holistic approach and think of exactly what we want to accomplish in this community. Abuse of power and micromanagement are the farthest from a panacea I could possibly think of.
The community will have its fair share of lunacy, unqualified posters, "me-too"ers, but that's what gives an online community breadth and depth. It gives a community character. The reason I came to HN in the first place was to engage in intensely scholarly discourse, and I have received that.
To keep it that way, let's be creative and not unnecessarily rename editorialized titles irrelevantly or hellban users that want discussion about the future of the community.