Everything We Know About Data.gov
sunlightlabs.com
sunlightlabs.com
Right now the site is short on data. Federal CIOs: There are hundreds of us waiting to do interesting things with your data. Invest in putting it up on Data.gov now. You will be rewarded.s
Here's the thing: They won't be rewarded.
In fact, it will make their life harder. Now a whole nation will be able to scrutinize every little expenditure. It's the ultimate "boss looking over your shoulder" situation. It's almost certainly going to be a real pain for them.
Don't misunderstand my point here. I love the idea of Government CIOs putting their data online. I think we should all encourage them to do it. I'm just saying people should be realistic and put themselves in the place of those they are trying to convince. Because when you do that you realize the sacrifice these CIOs are making to let their data out.
Given that I think the better argument is to tell CIOs how much better the world will be once they do this and how much we as citizen's will appreciate their sacrifice.
Telling a federal CIO: "Make this data available because people will be able to do amazing things with it, and you have the capacity to create whole industries out of your data, elevating the importance of you and your agency" seems a lot more viable of a sell than: "sacrifice yourself for the common good"
---------------------------
"Make this data available because people will be able to do amazing things with it," - Not only do I not really care, I see a sudden new constituency that will be making new demands on me in the future to improve my new service.
"and you have the capacity to create whole industries out of your data," - so, I'm begging for new interest groups to be looking over my shoulder? Oh boy.
"elevating the importance of you and your agency" - Bullshit! Elevating the importance of the monied interests based on the "industry" you just promised me! 'course, I might be able to extract rent, but it would take some time to entice regulatory capture...
Oh, and despite you not mentioning it, I still hear "Budget and Expenditure Oversight by citizens" loud and clear.
---------------------------
I still don't think you're quite putting yourself in the shoes of a generic government executive here. The thing is, if there really was something in it for them, they'd have already voluntarily opened up their data, instead of being forced.
There's only so much low-hanging fruit before things start to better resemble pulling teeth.
Again, you could be absolutely right. But in my experience very few people openly speak about being power hungry and those that do are far too aggressive to work as a Government bureaucrat.
It's not "their data". It's OUR money.
Various interest groups already have access. The only thing that changes with "open data" is that the folks providing the money will be able to see where it's going.
CIOs who have been captured by interest groups are going to be in trouble. Since that's basically all of them....
Or, to put it another way, if I were the CIO of [generic agency] looking to move up in the federal government, getting more data out there is a good way to position myself for a higher-up CIO-type role.
It's a somewhat crass way to look at it, and that's certainly not how I'd make a public case to the agencies, but if we're talking about how CIOs are disincentivized from releasing data because it might make them look bad, we ought to also consider that they're incentivized to release some data because doing so makes them look good.