All other things being equal, the person with experience in the specific tools the organisation uses will get the job.
Its just an unfortunate consequence of the industry we are in.
You are of course free to not chase the bleeding edge tools in your spare time, and youll probably stay employed just fine. But there is a risk you can be left behind or miss opportunities.
The people who were hacking on early IOS, Rails, Scala etc are todays experts enjoying niche markets. The people who didnt are working on VB or PHP for a Sausage factory somewhere.