To mount the argument that engineers and critics should be focusing on rehabilitating Musk's proposal rather than shooting it down, one of the following needs to be plausible:
(a) that door-door transit times on Musk's system will be significantly better than the HSR plan
(b) that construction and operation of Musk's plan will be significantly cheaper than HSR
(c) some X factor makes Musk's plan more attractive
There are compelling arguments against (a) and (b):
(a) because Musk's system can't reuse existing urban rights of way, it terminates far from either city center. It gets a "~30 minute" estimate, which message boards are eager to latch onto, by waving a magic wand and turning Hayward into San Francisco and Sylmar into Downtown LA. If that was a viable strategy, SWA would still be relying on Islip to service NYC.
(b) Musk's estimated tunneling and el track costs are so low that, were they viable, they'd revolutionize all of the rest of urban planning. For instance, Musk proposes to lower the cost of running viaduct by an entire order of magnitude. No comparable tunnel has been built for anything like what Musk proposes his tunneling costs will be. And the expenses he lays out make optimistic assumptions about the routes he'll be able to use, especially through the mountains.
It's gotta handily beat 2hrs 28min for the route people actually care about, OR be substantially cheaper. These aren't nits: they're the entire motivation for the proposal.
Facts, like tweets, have a size limit. "Hyperloop will connect areas relatively near to sf and la" is too long. "Hyperloop will connect sf and la" is a shorter, and therefore better, fact.
But yeah, screw those guys. Much more fun to solve the problems.
For example, I think the discussions of headway at the beginning of this article are very good, and he lays out both problems and potential solutions, albeit ones that make the system less useful.
However, by the time we reach the end, we get crap like "Clearly he's unfamiliar with the Cypress Street Viaduct." Yes, I'm sure Elon Musk has never heard of that, sure. I'm sure he didn't research earthquakes at all when making his statement. Come on, really?
This kind of nonsense weakens the article considerably, because readers will tend to concentrate on the weakest aspects of it, not the strongest.