After the Car Crash
hackerfactor.com
hackerfactor.com
But, the other part of the problem, is that people without insurance often come to the ER when they are ill, because they haven't established a relationship with a doctor or clinic. So, when they get sick, they go to the ER and purchase the most expensive care possible for their earache or sore throat.
Think about it, in the ER, we are trained and prepared to save lives in a heart attack, keep you alive long enough to have an operation if you get shot in the chest, or administer antidotes in case you get bitten by a rattle snake. We have all that equipment lying around just in case, and we're trained to use it. But, many of our patients have ear infections, runny noses, back aches and sore throats. Not exactly cost effective care.
A big reason for the lack of transparency in hospitl billing is that there are different tiers of payment depending on insurance. The hospital negotiates different rates with different categories of insurers.
Out of network private insurance pays full price or at times refuses to pay full price. In-network private insurance generally negotiates a 70-80% rate. Medicare and state public insurance generally pays a 15-50% rate. Non-Insured patients get billed at the full rate, but generally only 20-30% of those people fully pay their bills. So, many hospitals will give you a discount if you pay cash within a month or two of your visit.
Also, doctors aren't able to bill by the time they spend with you. Because of Medicare, the whole industry pays per diagnosis. So, if you get diagnosed with a pneumonia, Medicare pays a flat rate no matter how long you stay in the hospital, either 1 day or 10.
Finally, most hospitals, if they are making money at all, are operating on a 1-2% profit margin. It doesn't take much for them to go under, and they often need and get subsidized from the state or federal level.
15 years ago, I was very Conservative politically, thinking that market forces would sort it all out. But, the longer I work in health care, the more I think that we should just go to a single party payer system. I actually think that it would actually eliminate a lot of bureaucracy and cut a lot of costs. It'd be a hard sell in this country, though.
That's one of the biggest goofs of the American medical system. Trying to treat catastrophic care and routine care in exactly the same way makes it difficult to craft a system that works. The right insurance policy to pay a $50,000 accidental injury claim is not the right policy to get $25 worth of tetracycline. In trying to combine an insurance policy against large unforeseen medical costs with a prepaid, tax-free, employer sponsored routine care spending account, we've created an ungainly monster that just about does neither. Like those ridiculous "boat-cars" they tried to build in the 60's. Look! Its a boat and a car! No, its a car that barely drives and a boat that barely floats.
I find the entire thought of the health care system being private to be completely unnerving, and as you put it, insane. Why a man has to worry about his bodily well-being to the extent that if he has to give up his life savings for an accidental injury is confusing to me. This hardly even seems civilized, much less wise.
It not only makes no sense individually, it is also insane as a whole - by not covering preventative care for everyone you are increasing the virulence of your disease outbreaks, and even in non-contagious diseases and conditions you're still spending much more money in the end than if you nipped the problem in the bud via regular checkups and whatnot.
I know most of HN is American, and you have to excuse me for saying this, but as someone who's never lived long-term in the US your health care situation seems like something out of a bad dream. I cannot imagine the fear that you guys live with - the fear that I'm about to face in a couple months time. Oy.
If you're interested in buying supplemental Health Insurance, may I suggest reading Consumer Reports section on Health Insurance: http://www.consumerreports.org/health/insurance/health-insur...
They're a non-profit consumer advocacy company, and my $25 yearly subscription to their website pays for itself every single year. Great information and great advice.
For the record, the company's offering is through Aetna - and my brief overview online comes up with some pretty bad horror stories. What's the general impression of them on HN?
When I had to buy insurance on my own I ended up with KP after similar online research, scared off by the stories too, but there seem to be horror stories about all the providers; as far as I can tell, at best you can only choose a lower probability of them.
They lack transparency; they are overly complicated industries.
It should not be difficult to see how this encourages bubbles. In such industries, it'd be difficult to guess the real value being created, and we know from psychological research that people are apt to create speculative bubbles even without being given this nugget (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_behavior).
Was it?
I've heard a rather compelling argument that the cause of the 2001 recession wasn't Sept 11 or the dot-com bubble, but the huge drop off in corporate IT spending after Y2K. The enterprise software market enjoyed a huge run-up from 1996-2000 as enormous companies replaced their aging COBOL mainframes with new Y2K-compliant enterprise Java systems. Most of the Indian IT consultancy market owes its existence to this, and many other domestic firms (notably Sun Microsystems) also benefited heavily from it. The consumer dot-com bubble was a relative sideshow compared to this. And enterprise software is about as price-opaque as you can get.
When Y2K rolled around and nothing much happened, all that spending evaporated. Suddenly, all these companies that had hired a bunch of mediocre Java-monkeys to do quick Y2K fixes found themselves without customers.
It does seem a bit different though; in the examples he cites, the industries themselves collapsed, perhaps because of outdated technology and lack of transparency. In the tech industry, the tech industry's replacement of its own outdated technology created a huge bubble, and then collapsed once that bubble was no longer necessary.
Still, the raw numbers don't paint an accurate picture of what the early US was like. Consider this:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Battle_of_Franklin
Tennessee was once considered to be "the West". Gives you an idea of how settled the country was at the time, and the difficulty of crossing the Appalachians in those times.
Whether an application is text based or GUI has nothing to do with how effective it is.
Paperless, pull-down menus, and intelligent forms can be programmed either way. In fact, many text-based systems are much more effective than GUIs because they are simpler; the user never has to worry about the mouse.
I have personally "deconverted" 3 large scale systems from GUI back to the original text based system, then enhanced those systems to do what was needed. In each case (which flushed over $10 million down the toilet), the PHBs thought the move from text to GUI would magically solve all their problems.
Too bad those PHBs knew nothing about systems analysis, business processes, or project management. Apparently, neither does OP.