The actual legal details may be different, but that's how I see this case.
The actual legal details may be different, but that's how I see this case.
So if you "shout" on a public square (blog, post, etc.) you can't tell which group of people can and can not hear what you say.
The bar example would be fit for websites that raise paywalls, or some sort of access control.
That's idiotic, it's just another case where the judge is 20 years behind current affairs, he is judging something he clearly doesn't understand.
Craigslist told a patron they couldn't come in any more. The patron put on a fake mustache and tried to come in the back door.
Would you support someone scraping a blog to repost it elsewhere? Do you support crawlers that don't respect robots.txt? I don't see a problem with Craigslist saying 'No, you can't scrape our users content to post on your website'.
The exact details of which laws and how the court case went may not be correct, but at a theoretical level the website as open-to-public bar/store/etc is a perfectly valid analogy.
Fake mustaches for everyone!
It's actually pretty narrow. If you have received sufficient notice that you are no longer allowed to access a resource (in this case, the cease and desist letter), then you can't use technical measures to mask who you are and try to access the resource.
> It's actually pretty narrow. If you have received sufficient notice that you are no longer allowed to access a resource, then you can't access the resource.
Isn't the ruling considering automated scraping in some way different from normal browsing?
They don't have any reason to, so they don't, but they could.
It's hilarious that you would claim that one strained meatspace analogy is completely wrong, and your other strained meatspace analogy is completely right.
This is why laws in one context should not be mapped by analogy over to another context; they should be derived from the fundamental moral principle that the original law codified.
An open bar to the public? At a bar you have a degree of physical contact which conveys info you can not have via internet, that's why the 'square' example fits better (imho). But example apart, I'm with you on this: the court case sets a dangerous precedent.
I'm so tired of hearing this from hackers who have never taken a law class or picked up a book. Many hackers are abysmally ignorant of the law, and not all that good at critical thinking either. Some of those won't even listen to an explanation of how it does work, but double down on their ignorance and throw a tantrum instead.