I haven't been successfully proxied in a very long time and I'm an awful sc2 player (you see many more proxies in bronze than silver). A standard build order will crush a proxy 99/100 assuming the players are vaguely close in skill.
Actually, some of the recent WCS games are great examples; there's a reason why people will proxy or 6 pool. Sometimes it really does come down to luck, as in whether you scout at a specific time or not.