Comparing World of Warcraft to Second Life is like comparing Monopoly (the board game) to Lego blocks. The former has definite, artificial rules and objectives, the latter is an open-ended kit. To put it another way, the former is like living in someone else's imagination, the latter encourages you to use your own imagination. Or:
WoW = paint by numbers
SL = paints and a blank canvas
It seems clear why WoW has more users: most people believe they have no creative ability (sadly).