This is demonstrably not the case with cell phone service providers.
Mobile telephony providers use deliberately confusing pricing to prevent price comparison. They use contract lock in to prevent customers switching contracts. They exploit the apathy and inertia of customers.
What would work in an ideal situation is not what would work with the situation we have. Tightly regulated, often government owned, communication networks are being deregulated, split off from those government owned companies, while expanding into new markets.
We need regulation to prevent incumbents from exploiting their government-subsidized position, and to protect naive users from themselves.
There are many providers now who don't require contracts. Every provider in the US has some sort of prepaid / no contract plan. The prices are much better than contract plans too, at least in the US.
> We need regulation to prevent incumbents from exploiting their government-subsidized position, and to protect naive users from themselves.
No, you highlighted one of the problems. The government needs to stop backing monopolies / oligopolies and allow competition to flourish. Government involvement always compounds itself. Subsidization and promotion requires regulation later to compensate for the lack of a free market.
In fact, a completely free market is an anarchy. So not only will you get monopolies and price fixing, you'll also get armed gangs that run around and steal your stuff.
That having said, regulation should be as minimal as possible, to avoid unwanted side effects, therefore I'm not convinced that regulating away roaming charges completely is the best approach - IMHO it would be better to just allow everyone to get local rates without having to change the SIM card (see my other post for details).
1) It's not a market – there are not enough competing companies. (Which is the case of network operators.)
2) Customers don't make optimal market decisions.
Due to other unnecessary government regulation. Regulations always have a snowball effect.
> 2) Customers don't make optimal market decisions.
That's the customer's problem, not the government's. It benefits customers who do make optimal decisions.
This is simply not true. If it was not regulated at all, the situation would be worse. This is an industry that has a natural tendency to become mono/oligo-polic. (Similarly to water supply inustry.)
> That's the customer's problem, not the government's. It benefits customers who do make optimal decisions.
That deserves a longer discussion but I'll try to sum it up. One example of a regulation that helps customers make better decisions is that misleading advertisment is banned. When I say regulation, I mean that the customers collectively decided that it would be better for everyone if misleading ads were banned. There's absolutely nothing wrong with this.
Most of the comments are from customers who feel overcharged by their providers, who have had a pretty free market in which to operate over the last number of decades.
Governments have no business dictating simple contractual agreements such as this
But they do have a business dictating that monopolies/oligopolies can't screw their customers, which is what is happening with roaming charges in Europe.
So long as governments allow adequate competition the markets will meet customer demands
See above, the operators have had many years to sort this out and have not. Your ideology seems to have run up against an edge case.
Did you even read the article? The whole point of the new regulations is to allow competition between providers of different countries in a common EU telecoms market (as opposed to the current situation where individual countries are effectively silo'd off). I'd love an explanation as to how exactly that's "anti free market".
Yeah, especially in the "market for lemons"....
Governments have always regulated phone service.