Isn't this exactly what someone would have said about the NSA spying on us even just a few months back? Did we learn from that AT ALL or just anytime we don't like a theory we will call that person a tin foil hat wearing nutcase?
Isn't this exactly what someone would have said about the NSA spying on us even just a few months back? Did we learn from that AT ALL or just anytime we don't like a theory we will call that person a tin foil hat wearing nutcase?
The NSA is a different case. We do not know anything about it, except from the leaks. But we do know things about Tor.
a). Actively developed, follows the best principles possible. Open discussions in IRC, active mailing list, developers who respond to queries.
b). Highly researched by some of the best universities in the world. Cambridge and Waterloo come to mind instantly.
c). There has not been a single case of mistrust on their part that should make someone suspicious about them.
The day Tor does something like this, not only they lose their funding, they lose users and they become a dead project. With so much reputation at stake -- and they are respected people in the community -- Dingledine and Mathewson doing something like this? I don't think so.
This story is neither helpful nor enlightening in that regard as it has no evidence. Just mere speculation and insinuation.
There is value in discussing these conspiracy theories, if only to disseminate information and allow others to determine their own risk assessment. The conflict of interest inherent in a law enforcement agency funding a tool for circumventing detection is enough to raise alarm bells for some classes of users.
Completely agree, but its a little silly for the person who was just proven wrong to continue to heap the burden of proof on everyone but themselves.
I'd be more wary of NSA contributing code directly or through anon HUMINT accounts, hoping some of it slips through.