> wonder how much of this is actually in our direct control, and about the quality of the simple answers we give to shame people into exercising or dieting.
There's a contingent of people who find this attitude morally offensive. They worked hard for their health and are disgusted by those who want an easy way... and also people who didn't work hard to stay thin and are thin anyways like the self-congratulatory notion that they're doing something right.
Every time a new weight-loss tech appears you get people ranting about diet and excersize and the offensive nature of this "shortcut".
I'm reminded how Socrates was offended by the growth of writing because it was somehow morally inferior to memorization.