This isn't wishful thinking. It's simply recognition of the fact that feeling materially superior to others is only one of many routes to happiness.
If income doubles for the poor and quadruples for the rich (Cowen's postulated mechanism of increasing inequality), the poor have many new sources of happiness. For example, currently only 38% of the poor have a Playstation or XBox [1]. If the income of the poor doubles, probably every poor person could gain some happiness from video games.
[1] https://explore.data.gov/Energy-and-Utilities/Residential-En...