"Controller" is one of those terms that has meant a lot of different things at different times and in different systems. I agree that the same code asset (whether it's called a controller or whatnot) that handles user input should not be responsible for implementing a rule like "new users get emailed." At the same time, I also don't think such a rule belongs in your model layer. It should go in its own class (sometimes called a service, sometimes also called a controller). So the controller-managing-ui calls the controller-defining-behavior to make changes to the model.