Regarding the first, though, if we need to produce X horsepower for Y hours, then we can do it by using Z gas + Z' gas, or Z gas plus an idea for a more efficient engine. Ideas absolutely replace energy. They can't, so far as I can see, replace the last bit of energy, but we're nowhere near that.
Yes, I said as much.
"Efficiency gains aren't going to cut it with the energy consumption dynamics we have."
Maybe not; that's a broader question. The point is that you can displace some need for energy with efficiency gains or alternatives. The more energy you're using, the more of a difference an idea can make, since ideas tend to mean proportional improvements in efficiency (though not necessarily large proportions).
Whether it's sufficient is a huge question that would require a lot more attention than I'm able to give this right now (which is why I've persisted in staying out of the mainline of the discussion here).