I would say its fair, would you feel safe if all bombs only had this switch from the 50s?
I would say its fair, would you feel safe if all bombs only had this switch from the 50s?
That's not 1 in a million, that's 1 in 3.
Based on this tiny sample, here's the lottery analogy:
The lottery will flip 4 coins that have a 37.5% chance of being heads.
If you roll 4 heads lots of people die. So, just using this very inadequate sample from a single declassified document, you could estimate that a misfired bomb has a 2% chance of detonation (37.5%^4).
Obviously none of us know the real dataset, but my point is simply that it's not comforting that so many safety measures failed. (Which, as it happens, is also the opinion of the author of the original report in the article.)
That was exactly my point, that with such little data you cannot judge the probability.
I suppose they could have neglected to put a fuse in the circuit which should have protected it against a surge that would damage some very expensive equipment (not to mention cause nuclear detonation.) But I don't know. I wasn't there to see and I didn't read the report. And we all know fuses fail as well - would that be the fourth out of five failsafes?
To answer your question, no - I honestly would not feel safe. But "dramatically close" is different altogether. When I think "dramatically close" I think about the time my kid ran into the street and I grabbed him from in front of a car... I needed to act urgently to avoid disaster.
I could be wrong though (and often am.)