Electric Bike Review: We Ride the Pacific E-Bike Terra 7-Speed
treehugger.com
treehugger.com
Anyway, I will save my detailed rant for another day... but I think the reason Americans hate cycling is that the bikes that are marked towards them suck. A simple, traditional (steel!) road bike with a chain guard and eyelets for a rack and fenders would be cheaper, more reliable, and more flexible than most of the crap people are trying to sell today. I don't get it.
If you are really going to fly down the road at 20 mph, you cannot use caliper brakes. They won't have the stopping power or "bite" you need to stop quickly. If they get wet or dusty, then for get abou tit. Ditto for suspension if you are going to be making a turn at 20 mph or even 10. At speeds above 10 you really have a motorbike.
I work in san jose and saw some guy on a, as you put it, simple traditional steel roadbike with some kind of gas motor on it, going about 20. He tried to take a gentle turn along Tasman in front of Cisco building D or something and almost lost it. It was busy traffic and he could have died if he had gone down.
These things aren't bicycles with electric motors. They are motorbikes. These are not the same things. The handling is all different ( you lean into and push into turns ). A serious bicylist might know what I'm talking about. I think the difference is the motor. :) The torque it makes has different characteristics than a bicycle with a fast rider on it.
Executive summary: be careful out there. It's harder than it looks.
As far as hating bicycling...I don't...but I'm not going to get killed for the sake of commuting since bicycles on roads meant for cars are more or less incompatible in traffic.
You don't need suspension to turn a heavy bicycle. Look at all the tandems and cargo bikes without suspension. (I routinely load 35 pounds of groceries onto my bike without even thinking twice. Handling is barely affected, if at all.)
Caliper brakes develop plenty of stopping power, even in the rain. I have gone down hills fairly quickly (say, 35mph) only to encounter a red light -- and caliper brakes work just fine for stopping the bike quickly. (I have also ridden bikes with disc brakes. They also work very well, but are unnecessary if you are not riding through mud.) I am sure they are not adequate for stopping a motorcycle driving on the freeway, but that is a completely different case. The forces involved are an order of magnitude apart. This is an electric bicycle with a top speed of 20 miles an hour.
I am especially confounded with your statement, "At speeds above 10 you really have a motorbike." 10 what? At 10 miles an hour, you are struggling to balance a bicycle. Stopping and turning is not going to be a problem, even if you have a battery.
As far as hating bicycling...I don't...but I'm not going to get killed for the sake of commuting since bicycles on roads meant for cars are more or less incompatible in traffic.
This is completely false. Bicycles can use the road as well as cars can, as long as the cyclist obeys the same laws as the motorist. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicular_cycling
(Yes, drunk drivers or psychopaths might hit you. But plenty of people die in car accidents, too, and nobody has any qualms about taking their car on a public street.)
(As an aside, I am not even going to comment on your anecdote of someone "almost losing it" while turning. That could be due to anything, most likely a flat tire.
Continuing along the path of making hasty generalizations from personal experiences -- I have crashed my bike. I did not die. Therefore nobody dies in cycling accidents...)
I also disagree with your statement that this is not an electric bike. It is, and it is marketed as such. It has bicycle geometry and bicycle weight, and notably lacks a pair of heavy-ass gyroscopes. This is going to handle like a cargo bike.
Have any of you converted a regular bicycle to electric DIY-style? I see articles about that on the net. I'm wondering if it's worth it to do that. Would appreciate pointers.
Then again I am single, and don't own a place, but it's a great tradeoff when possible IMO. The issue with all city's being dirty, smelly, dangerus places to live is mostly a solved problem. I also have a lower enviermental impact than most american's living in "eco frendly" housing.
PS: Granted, I also make far more money than most people so I can afford to living in a nice highrise, but I think it's a great option which can quickly scale.
Was it worth it? To me, yes. Riding the bike is FUN. If you miss the strenuous workouts do what I did Saturday, and turn the motor off for all or part of your ride.
The bionx 250 maxes out at about 17 mph for me. It really makes a huge difference on the hills. With my battery enclosed in one of those nylon 'trunks' you can't even really tell it is an electric bike without looking closely. But this thing is a couple years old now and I'm sure isn't state of the art anymore. If I was buying today I'd definitely look at the non-kit, pre-built options. I spent hours getting everything the way I wanted it--enjoyable hours for me, at least.
Within the US, something like this would only work in city centers...people aren't going to ride their electric bike 15 miles to work each way, especially when you throw in the fact that a) they're wearing business attire, b) the weather is lousy for this in a lot of the country a lot of the time, c) they already have a car and our entire infrastructure is built around letting them use it.
Even within cities, there are only a handful where it's not too hot or too cold too much of the year for this to be worth it.
I think small hybrids & electrics are the future of transportation. Plus more people cramming into cities and using public transportation, not to mention things like telepresence may mean that fewer people need to commute to work in the first place.
But millions of people in the mid-west US riding their electric bicycles to work each day? Not gonna happen :)
I suppose the bike riding crowd is already keen to the cons of bike travel (lack of comfort, exposure to weather, etc), but I'd be game to exchanging my car to a powerful electric motorcycle, at least in the summer. Although my wife wouldn't be too keen on the idea.
http://www.blackbirdsf.org/courierracing/images/herse_porteu...
If my office actually had proper secure bike parking, I might get one of these to replace my monthly metrocard.
However, the problem is the same for electric bikes as it is for good quality push bikes: theft. Bicycles get stolen like nothing else in a lot of places. In cities where bicycle transport is common (The places I have experienced this have been Amsterdam & Beijing), they seem to have arrived at an inelegant solution to this: Cheap bikes you can afford to lose. That way you can rely on a combination of crappy wheel lok (no need to tie to a pole), low resale value & indifference to losing a bike or two a year.
For me, this is what keeps me from replacing my driving with cycling more often.
Here (Australia), anyone of age age can ride a bike pretty much anywhere for just the purchase cost of the bike, but to ride a motorbike I need to be of a certain age and have a license. I also need to page yearly rego and insurance, and pay stamp duty on top of the purchase price.
At the moment, I think there's still a reasonably clear division, but with improvements in battery life and capacity, and better motors soon there won't be a lot separating an electric bike from a scooter or basic motorbike. At which point I'm sure some bureaucrat will notice and well... we all know what will happen then :(
Also for a ton of links: http://www.electric-bikes.com/bikes/index.html