What Mugshots Mean For Public Data
hilarymason.com
hilarymason.com
* The surrounding context in which public data is presented (sort of the flip side, the "responsibility" side, of the coin whose other side is "collection copyright").
* The promotion of the data; for instance, the extent to which data is packaged to have higher rank on search engines (or, for that matter, its availability on search engines at all).
So it's not that mugshots aren't public data, so much as that there is public data that (a) shouldn't be packaged for search engines (Redditors, with their "no doxxing" policy, should have no trouble understanding this) and (b) shouldn't be packaged in ways that create bogus implications.
Mugshot sites do both.
We already have a way to check someone's criminal record - why the need for public access to a record of someone being arrested - even though no charges might have been filed?
Now whether that data should be public for all time (especially for those who were not charged with a crime or found non guilty) is a different story.
With this in mind, once a record of an arrest has been published, an official published record must persist, so that it can be linked with the outcome. Otherwise those who republish indiscriminately (or worse, those whose intent is to defame) will be able to define the "truth" as they see fit.
I consider this a prime example of why the US needs a constitutional privacy amendment. In many European countries police and reporters are forbidden to reveal an arrestee's name until charges have been laid against the person, and some governments (eg the UK, from whom our legal system derives) have been considering granting anonymity during trial for defendants accused of sex crimes, since even a false accusation can wreck someone's life completely, and accusations of rape or child abuse are more likely to result in vigilante action than accusations of murder.
It's very unclear what "public interest" is served by making these available in the first place.
It is intended to prevent secret arrests. It is absolutely sucky for individuals to have their arrests made public, but the consequences of enabling secret arrests would be terrible for the country as a whole.
I think this entirely misses the point. The point is that we should enforce, and to the extent needed, enhance, our blackmail and extortion laws to deal with these morally repugnant businesses. Under no circumstances should either the mugshot sites or a site like RipoffReport.com be able to solicit thousands of dollars under the threat that they will continue to disparage and embarrass their victims unless they pay. Google should not be helping these sites either - at least in the case of RipoffReport.com they are actually helping them carry out an extortion scheme against millions of people. Both the sites themselves and any site that helps them achieve their evil goals must be punished.
I think the best approach is shutting down the avenues of payment, so that we can eliminate any way for people to benefit from this behavior.
I'd prefer to see the problem addressed at the source: mugshots should be kept under some form of copyright, in addition to being kept confidential at least until a person is convicted. The copyright would drive these extortion sites underground, reducing impact on peoples' reputations, and the confidentiality would make it difficult to maintain an extortion site by choking off the data supply.
The people hosting this information to tarnish people's reputations in order to get them to pay are assholes. But the fact that your reputation can so easily be tarnished and that it matters so much is the root of the problem.
I mean if you really did believe the information was relevant and helped people make better decisions about others, you would want it to be public and easily accessible, right?
It's basically a catalog of mugshots of local people and what crimes they were charged with. The cashier told me people love that stuff.
I'm not sure what words of wisdom I have to offer about the intersection of technology and this behavior, but I can assure you that widespread publishing of mugshots is not new.
Funner fact: One of my friends used this to look up your address from your Facebook profile to see how far the bars you were talking about being at were from your home.